Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the rare picture book that works as both art and history lesson. Gerstein's illustrations are legitimately stunning—those foldout spreads of Petit suspended between the towers will take your breath away. The prose is spare and poetic, treating the whole affair as the beautiful, illegal, audacious act it was.
The 9/11 elephant in the room is handled with grace: one simple line at the end notes the towers are gone. For families ready to talk about it, this book is a gentle entry point. For families not ready, it might land harder than expected.
It's a Caldecott winner for a reason, and at 20+ years old, it still holds up beautifully. Not every kid will connect with the reflective, bittersweet tone, but for the right reader, this is a gem.
Age Fit
Best for ages 6-10. The reading level is accessible for early readers (grades 1-3), but the emotional depth and 9/11 subtext make it better suited for kids who can handle reflective, bittersweet stories. Older elementary kids will appreciate the history and artistry more fully.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Caldecott Medal winner with lyrical storytelling that celebrates human courage, artistry, and wonder. The tone is reverent and poetic, treating Petit's illegal stunt as a beautiful act of daring rather than recklessness. Models determination and following your passion, though the 9/11 connection adds a bittersweet layer that requires emotional maturity.
Imaginative
92
Gerstein's watercolor illustrations and dramatic foldout spreads create vertiginous drama and capture the poetry of an impossible feat. The book invites kids to imagine the audacity of throwing a rope between towers and dancing in the sky. It celebrates creativity, artistry, and the question 'what if?' in the most literal, breathtaking way possible.
Safe
75
No graphic content, but the implicit 9/11 context (the towers 'are no more') can be heavy for young kids who don't know the history, or triggering for families with personal connections. The high-wire act itself is presented beautifully but could cause anxiety in some sensitive kids. Generally safe but emotionally complex.
Enriching
90
Rich historical biography that introduces kids to Philippe Petit's 1974 feat, the World Trade Center, and the idea that art can be audacious and illegal and beautiful all at once. Sparks conversations about risk, passion, what we memorialize, and how we remember loss. The poetic language and Carnegie Medal recognition signal real literary merit.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Caldecott Medal and Carnegie Medal winner with gorgeous watercolor illustrations and dramatic foldout spreads that capture the vertigo
Introduces kids to a real historical moment (1974) and a fascinating person who pursued beauty and art in the most audacious way
Lyrical, poetic language that treats reading as an experience, not just information delivery
Sparks big conversations about risk, passion, memory, and loss without being heavy-handed
The 9/11 connection is handled with restraint—just a simple note that the towers 'are no more'—which can be profound for families ready to discuss it
⚠
What to Watch For
The ending acknowledges the towers no longer exist, which opens the door to 9/11 conversations—decide if your kid is ready for that
Some kids might find the high-wire imagery anxiety-inducing, especially the foldout spreads that emphasize the height
Best for kids who can handle bittersweet or reflective endings, not just happy resolutions
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think Philippe wanted to walk between the towers? Would you ever do something that risky for something you loved?"
"The book says the towers are 'no more.' Do you know what happened to them? (Gauge readiness first.)"
"Was it okay for Philippe to break the law to do his tightrope walk? When might breaking a rule be worth it?"
"What would it feel like to be up that high with nothing but a wire under your feet?"