Is the heart-eating scene actually shown?

Not directly. You see the villain lean over the body with a knife, and then you see the act reflected in the Lone Ranger's eye. It's heavily implied and very disturbing, even without the gore.

Is Johnny Depp's portrayal of Tonto offensive?

It was highly controversial at release. While Depp claimed some Native American heritage, many critics felt the performance relied on 'weird' eccentricities and stereotypes. It's a good entry point for a conversation about casting and representation.

Is it too scary for a 10-year-old?

For most 10-year-olds, yes. Between the cannibalism themes, the execution of the Rangers, and the massacre of the Comanche tribe, it's much heavier than a typical Marvel movie.

Is there any 'romance' content to worry about?

There is a subplot involving the Lone Ranger's love for his brother's wife, but it's handled very cleanly. No sex or nudity, just some pining and a few chaste moments.

The Lone Ranger – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Lone Ranger

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie2013

48%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

A bizarre, bloated, and surprisingly dark Western that trades the classic hero's journey for 149 minutes of tonal whiplash and CGI explosions.

31%

→

The Lone Ranger

movie

PG-13, 2013

48%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

A bizarre, bloated, and surprisingly dark Western that trades the classic hero's journey for 149 minutes of tonal whiplash and CGI explosions.

31%

Jump to

Also rated on

31%

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

The Lone Ranger is a fascinating failure. It wants to be Pirates of the Caribbean on a horse, but it's burdened by a script that’s far too dark and a runtime that's far too long. Johnny Depp’s performance as Tonto is polarizing at best, and the film’s attempts at heavy political commentary feel weirdly jammed into a movie that also features a psychic horse.

For a modern kid, this is a tough sell. It's not that it's 'old'—it's from 2013—it's just that it's a mess. If you're looking for a fun Western, there are better places to go. If you're looking for a Gore Verbinski spectacle, stick to the first Pirates movie.

Age Fit

Best for kids 12 and up who have the patience for a long runtime and the stomach for some surprisingly gruesome villainy. It is definitely not the lighthearted Disney adventure the marketing suggested.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The film attempts a buddy-comedy dynamic, but the tone is wildly inconsistent, swinging from slapstick humor to grim, realistic depictions of massacres and betrayal.

Imaginative

Director Gore Verbinski brings his signature visual flair and some genuinely creative, over-the-top action set pieces, particularly the final train chase.

Safe

Surprisingly violent for a Disney production. Features a villain who eats a human heart (mostly off-camera but clear), multiple cold-blooded executions, and a high body count.

Enriching

It touches on the dark side of American expansion and railroad corruption, but these themes are often lost in the noise of explosions and Johnny Depp's eccentricities.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The final train sequence is a masterpiece of action choreography, perfectly synced to the classic 'William Tell Overture.'
It offers a subversive take on the Western genre, framing the 'civilizing' forces of the railroad as the true villains.
The production design and practical effects are top-tier, giving the film a gritty, dusty reality that looks great on a big screen.

⚠

What to Watch For

The villain, Butch Cavendish, is genuinely disturbing; there is a scene where he cuts out and eats a man's heart (it's reflected in a character's eye, but the intent is clear).
The massacre of the Comanche people is depicted with a level of grimness that feels out of place in a movie that also features a horse standing in a tree wearing a hat.
At two and a half hours, the pacing is a slog; most kids (and adults) will lose interest long before the climax.

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think the movie chose to make the railroad company the bad guys instead of just the outlaws?"
"Tonto is a very different character here than in the old TV shows. Does his 'weirdness' feel like a real personality or a caricature?"
"The Lone Ranger refuses to kill his enemies at first. Is that 'justice' or just being impractical in a lawless world?"

Deep Dive

The Tonal Whiplash Problem

When Disney greenlit The Lone Ranger, they were clearly hoping to strike gold twice by pairing Gore Verbinski and Johnny Depp in another genre-reviving franchise. But where Pirates of the Caribbean found a perfect balance between supernatural horror and swashbuckling fun, The Lone Ranger trips over its own spurs. It can't decide if it's a gritty revisionist Western about the genocide of Native Americans or a wacky buddy-cop movie where a horse drinks beer.

The 'Heart' of the Matter

The film’s PG-13 rating is pushed to its absolute limit. William Fichtner’s Butch Cavendish isn't a cartoon outlaw; he’s a cannibalistic monster. The scene involving the Ranger's brother and his heart is the kind of thing that leaves a mark on younger viewers. It’s not just 'action violence'; it’s mean-spirited. This darkness makes the subsequent scenes of slapstick comedy feel jarring and, frankly, a bit tasteless.

Is it Worth the 149 Minutes?

Probably not. The first two acts are a repetitive cycle of captures and escapes that could have been trimmed by forty minutes without losing a single plot point. By the time the 'William Tell Overture' finally kicks in for the big finale, you might be too exhausted to enjoy it. If you do watch it, do it for the incredible practical stunts and the train sequence, but keep the remote handy for the many, many slow parts.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic