Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
The Ivies is a sharp, cynical look at what happens when achievement culture goes off the rails. It’s essentially a 'dark academia' thriller that swaps ancient libraries for SAT prep and admissions essays. It doesn't pull punches about how ugly the race for prestige can get.
If your teen is currently drowning in extracurriculars and stressing over their GPA, this might either be a cathartic 'I see you' moment or a bit too much reality. Either way, it’s a page-turner that handles its mystery well enough to keep them off their phones for a few hours.
Age Fit
Best for high schoolers (14+) who are starting to feel the heat of college applications. It’s too dark and cynical for most middle schoolers, but it hits the bullseye for teens who like Gossip Girl or One of Us Is Lying.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
42
The plot revolves around sabotage, lying, and cutthroat competition. It is a 'mean girls' dynamic dialed up to eleven, where characters are defined by their lack of kindness and cooperation.
Imaginative
68
It takes the very real, often boring world of college admissions and turns it into a high-stakes thriller. It's a sharp, creative use of a relatable setting.
Safe
82
As a YA thriller, it contains a murder and various forms of social and physical peril. It is safe for its intended teen audience but too intense for younger middle-grade readers.
Enriching
78
It serves as a brutal critique of the 'prestige at any cost' mindset. It exposes the toxicity of elite academic environments and asks hard questions about ethics and ambition.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Perfectly captures the mania of the modern college admissions industrial complex and the pressure teens feel to be perfect.
Fast-paced mystery that keeps the 'who-done-it' energy high while exploring the social hierarchy of an elite boarding school.
Unapologetic critique of privilege and the lengths people will go to maintain it when they feel entitled to a specific future.
⚠
What to Watch For
The protagonist, Olivia, isn't exactly a hero; she's complicit in a lot of the group's toxic behavior, which might frustrate readers looking for a moral center.
The levels of sabotage—like ruining someone's extracurriculars or tanking their reputation—can be a lot for kids already feeling school-related anxiety.
Contains references to murder, drug use, and the kind of high-level social manipulation that defines the 'thriller' genre.
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think the girls felt like getting into an Ivy was the only way to succeed?"
"Olivia stays in the group even when she knows they are toxic. When does loyalty become a liability?"
"If you found out a friend cheated to get a spot at a school you both wanted, what would you actually do?"
"Does the culture at Claflin Academy feel like a exaggeration of your school, or does it feel uncomfortably close to home?"
Deep Dive
The College Admissions Arms Race
Alexa Donne’s The Ivies arrived right in the wake of the real-world Varsity Blues scandal, and it leans hard into that zeitgeist. The setting, Claflin Academy, is the kind of place where students don't just want to succeed—they want to conquer. The 'Ivies' are a clique of five girls who have 'claimed' specific elite universities, vowing to sabotage anyone else who dares to apply to their chosen school.
When Emma, the girl who 'claimed' Harvard, is found dead after getting in, the story shifts from social commentary to a full-blown murder mystery. Olivia, our narrator, has to figure out which of her friends is a killer while maintaining her own standing in the admissions race.
What makes this book worth the read isn't just the mystery—it's the honesty about the pressure. It validates the feeling that the current system is rigged and insane. It’s a great pick for a kid who likes a 'noir' vibe but wants it set in a world they actually recognize. If they've already burned through everything by Karen M. McManus, this is the logical next step.
