Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
The Golden Dreidel is a fantastic corrective to the 'holiday special' landfill. Instead of a generic story about the 'spirit of the season,' it’s a legit portal fantasy that uses Jewish folklore to build a world as weird and wonderful as any wardrobe-accessed kingdom.
It is the rare book that manages to be culturally specific without feeling like a Sunday School lesson. Kushner treats the folklore with respect but prioritizes the adventure, making it a great pick for any kid who likes a good 'chosen one' story with a twist.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 7 to 12. Younger kids will love it as a nightly Chanukah read-aloud, while independent readers in the 3rd to 5th-grade range can handle the adventure solo.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
The story centers on family tradition and a protagonist who has to find her own internal wisdom and courage rather than relying on magic to do the work for her.
Imaginative
95
Ellen Kushner is a fantasy heavy-hitter. She takes the standard 'portal fantasy' trope and reskins it with rich, specific Jewish folkloric elements that feel fresh.
Safe
98
It is a middle-grade adventure book. The demons and riddles are standard fantasy fare, and the publisher, National Geographic/Charlesbridge, maintains high safety standards for this age group.
Enriching
94
It offers a meaningful cultural alternative to the dominant Christmas narrative, providing deep background on Jewish folklore beyond the surface-level holiday basics.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Ellen Kushner's writing brings a level of fantasy pedigree you don't usually see in holiday-themed kids' books.
It tackles Christmas envy head-on, giving kids who don't have a tree a magical world that is specifically theirs.
The focus on riddles and wisdom rewards cleverness over brute force, which is a great beat for middle-grade readers.
It draws on authentic folklore, introducing characters and creatures from Jewish myth that rarely get the spotlight in mainstream media.
⚠
What to Watch For
The spooky factor is present. There are demons and riddles that might feel a bit intense for very sensitive 6-year-olds, but it's well within the 'Narnia' level of peril.
The pacing is more like a traditional adventure story than a quick-hit modern graphic novel, so it works best for kids who can settle into a narrative.
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think Sara felt like she was missing out at the beginning of the book?"
"If you had to face a demon with a riddle, what riddle would you use to stump them?"
"How did Tante Miriam's gift change the way Sara saw her own family's traditions?"
"Which of the miracles Sara spun was your favorite?"
Deep Dive
The Jewish Nutcracker We Needed
For a long time, the options for Chanukah-themed media were either historical accounts of the Maccabees or very thin stories about latkes. The Golden Dreidel changes that by following the Nutcracker blueprint—a mysterious relative, a magical gift, and a journey to a hidden realm—but swapping out the Sugar Plum Fairy for demons and riddles from Jewish tradition.
Ellen Kushner is a massive name in adult fantasy (known for the Riverside series), and she doesn't dumb things down for the younger audience. The prose is sharp and the stakes feel real. Sara’s initial 'Christmas envy' is a relatable starting point for many kids, and the book's transition from that feeling of lack into a world of abundance and magic is handled with a lot of grace.
If your kid has already burned through Percy Jackson and is looking for more mythology-based fiction, this is a solid weekend read. It’s also a great choice for families looking to build a library of holiday books that actually have some meat on their bones. It’s short enough for a family read-aloud over the eight nights of the holiday but complex enough to keep a 10-year-old turning pages under the covers.