Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Elin Hilderbrand delivers her signature blend of coastal aesthetic and interpersonal drama, using a food blogger's grief retreat on Nantucket to unpack five decades of complicated female relationships.
While the setup sounds like a cozy beach read, the story dives quickly into marital secrets, career-ending social media gaffes, and long-simmering resentment among friends. It is engaging adult contemporary fiction, though entirely geared toward adult readers rather than a teen audience.
Age Fit
Written explicitly for an adult audience. Mature teens interested in contemporary multi-perspective drama can handle it, but the focus on marriage, grief, and long-term adult dynamics won't hold much appeal for younger readers.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
45
Deals with marital conflict, sudden spousal death, secret affairs, and social media scandals, though balanced by genuine themes of forgiveness and friendship.
Imaginative
55
Features a clever high-concept structure around phase-of-life friendships and food blogging, grounded in standard adult drama conventions.
Safe
62
Contains no physical violence or shock gore, but involves sudden spousal death, marital infidelity, alcohol use, and mature sexual references.
Enriching
60
Offers thoughtful reflections on long-term female friendships, processing sudden grief, and the gap between curated public lives and private reality.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Nuanced look at female friendships across different life stages, from high school roots to middle-age career pressure.
Vivid Nantucket backdrop complete with high-end catering, food blogging logistics, and coastal summer ambiance.
Relatable exploration of grief and the messy reality of piecing a life back together after sudden loss.
⚠
What to Watch For
Heavy adult themes including the abrupt fatal crash of a spouse, unfaithfulness in marriages, and intense relationship fallout.
Casual drinking and partying feature prominently throughout the retreat setting.
Online cancel culture subplots dealing with ruined professional reputations and public call-outs.
Conversation Starters
"How do high school friendships change over decades compared to adult friendships formed in your thirties?"
"Why do you think Hollis chose to process her grief through a hyper-curated event rather than taking quiet time alone?"
"What role does social media play in how people present their relationships versus what is actually happening behind closed doors?"
Deep Dive
Nantucket Drama with Adult Weight
The Five-Star Weekend takes a high-concept premise—gathering women from distinct chapters of a person's life under one roof—and grounds it in the messy friction of real-world history. When food blogger Hollis Shaw loses her husband in a sudden car accident following an argument, her decision to host a curated weekend on Nantucket becomes a vehicle for confronting hidden truths across all four guests.
For mature teens curious about adult contemporary fiction, the book moves fast and offers interesting commentary on public image versus private pain. Between Dru-Ann's corporate social media crisis and Brooke's marriage woes, the drama rarely stalls. However, parents should know it is written for adult trade fiction shelves, with heavy emphasis on marital fidelity, grief, and long-standing personal regrets.