Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is basically Sherlock Holmes for the 'girls in STEM' era, but it actually works because it's a good story first and a 'lesson' second. It doesn't lecture; it just lets these two geniuses be messy, smart, and adventurous.
It’s 2015-era writing, so it moves at a modern clip and doesn't suffer from the 'boring classic' syndrome. If your kid likes puzzles, history, or just watching two smart girls outwit a bunch of adults, this is an easy addition to the bookshelf.
Age Fit
Perfect for the 8-12 crowd. It’s a great 'step up' for kids who finished Enola Holmes or The Mysterious Benedict Society and want something with a bit more intellectual bite.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
The core of the book is a functional, if prickly, friendship between two girls with opposite worldviews—one driven by cold logic and the other by emotion and storytelling. It models intellectual curiosity and teamwork without being saccharine.
Imaginative
92
It’s a clever 'what if' scenario that smashes together Ada Lovelace and Mary Shelley in a steampunk-adjacent 1826 London. The world-building is creative, reimagining historical figures in a way that feels fresh rather than dusty.
Safe
95
Standard middle-grade mystery fare. There's some mild 'peril' involving a chase and a visit to a 19th-century prison, but nothing that would shock or upset a typical 8-year-old. No language or content issues to flag.
Enriching
94
It’s a stealth-education win. Kids pick up on logic, early computer science concepts (via Ada), and literary history without feeling like they're doing homework. It encourages girls to be weird, smart, and ambitious.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Reimagines historical icons like Ada Lovelace and Mary Shelley as relatable, clever girls rather than boring statues.
Heavy on logic and STEM concepts without the 'educational' aftertaste that usually kills the fun.
The chemistry between the 'Sherlock' (Ada) and 'Watson' (Mary) dynamic is genuinely funny and sharp.
Fast-paced enough to keep a modern kid engaged, unlike some older, slower 'classic' mysteries.
⚠
What to Watch For
Mild historical peril—the girls visit Newgate prison and deal with some sketchy suspects, but it’s handled with a light touch.
It plays fast and loose with actual history (it’s an 'alternate history'), so don't let your kid use it as their primary source for a history report.
Conversation Starters
"Ada uses logic for literally everything—when is logic better than feelings, and when does it make things harder?"
"If you could team up with any two famous people from history to solve a mystery today, who would you pick?"
"Mary Shelley eventually wrote Frankenstein—do you see any hints of her 'spooky' or creative side in this story?"
"The girls have to find 'loopholes in propriety' because of how girls were treated in 1826. What's a rule today that you think is just as silly?"