Look, this is objectively brilliant filmmaking. Peter Jackson took 60 hours of footage and created something that makes you feel like you're in the room with The Beatles in 1969. The creative insights are extraordinary, the restoration is mind-blowing, and if you're a music nerd, this is catnip.

BUT. Eight hours. EIGHT. And it's not eight hours of action-packed narrative—it's eight hours of watching people jam, chat, smoke, work through ideas, and occasionally have tense conversations. It's fly-on-the-wall documentary filmmaking at its finest, which means it's also slow.

For the right teen—the kid who plays guitar, who's obsessed with music history, who can actually sit still for more than 20 minutes—this is genuinely enriching and worth every minute. For everyone else? They'll tap out in episode one.

The WISE scores are high because the content itself is exceptional. The overall score reflects reality: most families won't finish this, and that's okay. It's a masterpiece for a specific audience, not a crowd-pleaser.