Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This isn't 'brain rot' fantasy; it's a well-constructed, highly addictive sequel that actually rewards the reader for paying attention to the lore.
It’s definitely for the kid who loves the 'aesthetic' side of TikTok or Pinterest—think dried roses, gold keys, and tragic romances. It’s safe, smart, and one of the few modern YA series that actually lives up to the hype without being overly cynical or needlessly graphic.
Age Fit
Best for 13 or 14 and up. Younger readers might find the romantic angst tedious or the darker curse elements a bit too creepy, but for the YA crowd, it's a bullseye.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
75
It deals with heavy emotional betrayal and the fallout of broken promises. While it’s not exactly 'clean' in the sense of being conflict-free, it handles the messiness of human (and magical) relationships with a grounded emotional core.
Imaginative
94
Stephanie Garber is a master of atmospheric, whimsical world-building. The magic feels tactile and the fairy-tale logic is clever rather than just being a retread of old tropes.
Safe
82
Safe for its intended teen audience. There's some violence—stabbings, vampire bites, and 'murderous spells'—and plenty of romantic tension, but nothing that would shock a modern 14-year-old.
Enriching
80
It’s a great study in boundaries and the danger of idealizing 'happily ever after.' It pushes readers to think about the cost of their desires and whether a person can truly change.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
The world-building is top-tier; it feels like stepping into a lush, dangerous storybook.
It avoids the 'middle book syndrome' by amping up the stakes and the emotional tension.
Evangeline is a protagonist who actually learns from her mistakes, even when her heart is pulling her the wrong way.
The 'Prince of Hearts' character is a masterclass in the 'villain you want to root for' trope.
⚠
What to Watch For
Romantic intensity: There's a lot of longing and 'enemies-to-lovers' tension that might be too much for younger kids.
Darker magic: Scenes involving blood, curses, and vampire-like bites get a bit more visceral than the first book.
Emotional manipulation: The story revolves around characters who lie and manipulate each other, which is the point, but worth discussing.
Conversation Starters
"If someone betrays you once, can you ever really trust them again even if the world is at stake?"
"Does Jacks actually care about Evangeline, or is he just using her for his own ends?"
"Why do you think Evangeline is so obsessed with a 'happily ever after' even when things are going wrong?"
"If you could cast a spell to fix a mistake, would you do it knowing there's always a price?"
