Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is what happens when a master storyteller decides to break all the rules in the best possible way. Reynolds and Raúl the Third created something that looks unlike anything else on the middle-grade shelf—and it works.
The superhero framing is brilliant because it lets kids process heavy stuff (divorce, anxiety, feeling powerless) through play and imagination. Portico isn't saving the world from aliens; he's saving the building's cat and trying to save his parents' marriage. It's grounded, real, and deeply validating for any kid who's ever felt responsible for fixing things they can't control.
The anxiety representation is particularly strong. Reynolds doesn't pathologize it or make it Portico's whole identity—it's just part of his experience, something he's learning to name and manage. Kids who live with anxiety will feel seen; kids who don't will gain empathy.
The format might throw some adults ('Is this a graphic novel? Poetry? A script?'), but kids don't care about genre labels. They just know it's fun to read, moves fast, and doesn't talk down to them. It's 2021 so still fresh, and the themes are timeless. This is a genuine win.
Age Fit
Best for ages 8-13, especially kids navigating family changes or their own big feelings. The innovative format and emotional depth will resonate most with upper elementary through middle school readers who are ready for honest conversations about divorce and anxiety.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Tackles divorce and childhood anxiety with warmth and age-appropriate honesty. Portico processes his parents' fighting through his superhero alter-ego, modeling healthy coping mechanisms. The story centers friendship, community care (he's constantly helping neighbors), and emotional awareness. Reynolds doesn't sugarcoat hard feelings but keeps the tone hopeful and supportive throughout.
Imaginative
92
The format itself is wildly creative—part graphic novel, part verse novel, part TV script, with illustrations by Raúl the Third. The superhero framing lets kids explore serious topics through imaginative play. Portico's apartment building becomes a castle, neighbors become citizens to protect, anxiety becomes 'worry wiggles.' It invites kids to see their own lives through a creative lens and validates using imagination as a processing tool.
Safe
90
No content warnings. The divorce storyline and anxiety representation are handled with care—parents fight but it's not violent or scary, just sad and real. Common Sense Media calls it a 'masterpiece' for how it handles these topics. The book gives kids language for big feelings without traumatizing them. No surprise deaths, no inappropriate content, just honest middle-grade emotional territory.
Enriching
94
This is a masterclass in emotional intelligence for kids. It normalizes anxiety, gives it a name (the frets, worry wiggles), and shows a kid actively trying to manage it. The divorce storyline validates kids' feelings about parental conflict while showing they're not responsible for fixing it. Plus it's genuinely entertaining—the format keeps pages turning, the humor lands, and Goodreads reviewers note kids find it 'fun and engaging.' Schneider Family Award Honor Book for its authentic portrayal of mental health.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Jason Reynolds (Newbery honoree) and Raúl the Third created something genuinely innovative—part graphic novel, part verse, part TV script, all heart
Gives kids vocabulary and validation for anxiety ('worry wiggles,' 'the frets') without being preachy or clinical
The divorce storyline is real but not traumatic—shows parents fighting without making it scary, validates kids' feelings without making them responsible
Portico's superhero identity is about helping others, not violence—he saves the building's cat, checks on neighbors, tries to protect everyone
Fast-paced and funny enough that reluctant readers actually finish it (multiple reviews confirm kids find it engaging)
⚠
What to Watch For
Parents are separating—it's handled well but some kids in stable homes might have questions about why people get divorced
Portico's anxiety is front and center; great for kids who relate, might be confusing for kids who don't yet understand what anxiety feels like
The experimental format is a feature not a bug, but very traditional readers might need a minute to adjust to the unconventional page layouts
Conversation Starters
"Portico calls his anxiety 'the frets' and 'worry wiggles.' Do you ever get those feelings? What does it feel like in your body?"
"Why do you think Portico imagines himself as a superhero? Does pretending ever help you deal with hard stuff?"
"Portico's parents keep sending him to check on neighbors 'in the meantime.' Why do you think they do that? Is it helping Portico or making things harder?"
"Who are the real superheroes in this story—the ones with actual powers or the ones helping their community?"