Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. As an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns from qualifying purchases, so if you buy a book or game through one of our links, we may earn a commission. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Strange the Dreamer is the kind of YA fantasy that reminds you the genre can be genuinely literary. Taylor's writing is stunning, her world-building is original and immersive, and she's not afraid to tackle difficult moral territory.

But let's be clear: this is not a light read. The backstory involves a god sexually assaulting human women, resulting in the birth of the godspawn who are central to the story. There's genocide, revenge, and deeply uncomfortable questions about complicity and inherited guilt. Some readers find the central romance beautiful and redemptive; others find it morally troubling given the power dynamics. It's sparked real debate, which means Taylor is doing something interesting—but also means this won't work for everyone.

For the right teen reader—someone who's 15+, loves complex fantasy, and is ready to sit with moral ambiguity—this is a rich, rewarding experience. For younger teens or anyone looking for straightforward adventure, it'll be too heavy and too slow. Know your kid.

Age Fit

Best for mature 15-18 year olds who love literary fantasy and are ready for complex moral questions alongside their adventure. The prose is beautiful but demanding, and the themes are genuinely heavy—this isn't for younger teens or anyone looking for light escapism.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

62

The book features complex moral questions and challenging themes including genocide, sexual assault, and forced pregnancy that are central to the plot. While Taylor handles these with literary care, the emotional weight is heavy. The romance is developed thoughtfully, but the context of the relationship (between oppressor's descendant and victim's descendant) adds moral complexity that may be uncomfortable. Not emotionally exploitative, but definitely not light fare.

Imaginative

92

Absolutely stunning world-building with a mythic lost city, blue-skinned gods, dream-weaving, and deeply original fantasy elements. Taylor's prose is lush and inventive—moths and nightmares, a citadel of murdered gods, characters with names like Lazlo Strange and the Godslayer. The dream mechanics and the mystery of Weep create genuine wonder. This is peak YA fantasy imagination, reminiscent of her Daughter of Smoke & Bone creativity.

Safe

55

Common Sense Media rates this 15+ for good reason. Contains sexual assault (a god forces himself on human women, resulting in pregnancies), violence including mass murder of gods, and mature themes of genocide and revenge. The sexual content is not gratuitous but is present and contextually disturbing. One reviewer called it 'morally repugnant' for its handling of racism and classism, though others praised the moral complexity. Not appropriate for younger teens to encounter unexpectedly.

Enriching

78

Grapples with genuinely difficult questions about inherited guilt, cycles of violence, and how to break free from the sins of previous generations. The librarian protagonist models intellectual curiosity and courage. Explores themes of identity, agency, and the cost of justice versus revenge. The writing itself is enriching—Taylor's prose is beautiful and demands attention. However, the moral framework around the central relationship has sparked legitimate debate about whether it handles power dynamics appropriately.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Taylor's prose is genuinely gorgeous—this is YA fantasy that reads like literary fiction, with language that demands to be savored
World-building is next-level: a lost city called Weep, murdered gods, dream mechanics, and mythology that feels both ancient and original
Tackles genuinely difficult moral questions about inherited trauma, cycles of violence, and whether love can bridge impossible divides
The protagonist is a bookish librarian who gets to be the hero of his own epic—great for kids who see themselves in the quiet, curious ones
For teens ready for complex narratives, this offers real intellectual and emotional challenge alongside the fantasy adventure

⚠

What to Watch For

This is firmly 15+ territory—sexual assault is part of the backstory (a god forcing himself on human women), and while not graphic, it's central to the plot
Heavy themes of genocide, revenge, and moral complicity that may be too much for younger or more sensitive teens
The central romance has sparked debate: is it a beautiful bridge between enemies, or does it romanticize a power imbalance? Depends on the reader
Dense, slow-burn pacing—this is not a quick read, and some teens will bounce off the literary style
Ends on a cliffhanger, so you're committing to the duology

Conversation Starters

"Lazlo and the godspawn are both dealing with the sins of the previous generation—do you think people inherit responsibility for what their ancestors did?"
"The gods were killed for real reasons, but their children are innocent. How do you break a cycle of violence when both sides have legitimate grievances?"
"What did you think about the romance? Can love exist in a healthy way when there's such an imbalanced history between two people?"
"If you could enter dreams like Lazlo, what would you want to explore or create?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Strange the Dreamer Laini Taylor? Put this WISE score on your site