Stacey's Mistake – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Stacey's Mistake

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2014

89%

WISE Score

4.6

Amazon

Stacey tries to blend her 'cool' NYC life with her suburban besties, proving that mixing friend groups is a recipe for high-stakes middle school drama.

Stacey's Mistake

book

2014

89%

WISE Score

4.6

Amazon

Stacey tries to blend her 'cool' NYC life with her suburban besties, proving that mixing friend groups is a recipe for high-stakes middle school drama.

4.6

Jump to

Also rated on

4.6

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Stacey's Mistake is a solid, high-quality read that actually respects a kid's intelligence. It’s part of the massive Baby-Sitters Club graphic novel revival, which has been a godsend for getting kids to put down the iPad and actually look at a page.

It’s not 'brain rot'—it’s a well-constructed story about social dynamics that are genuinely difficult for kids to navigate. If your kid is already into the series, this is a must-buy. If they aren't, this is a great entry point because of the change in scenery. It’s wholesome without being boring, and modern enough that it doesn't feel like a relic from the 80s.

Age Fit

This is the 'sweet spot' for 8-to-12-year-olds. It’s sophisticated enough for middle schoolers but clean enough for a mature 7-year-old who is obsessed with the BSC series.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

It's the Baby-Sitters Club—the gold standard for friendship-driven, emotionally grounded stories. It models apologizing when you've been a jerk and navigating the friction of different social circles without being preachy.

Imaginative

While it's realistic fiction rather than high fantasy, the New York City setting provides a great 'fish out of water' exploration for kids used to the suburbs. It encourages kids to imagine different lifestyles and social dynamics.

Safe

Extremely safe. There's no violence, no inappropriate language, and no 'surprise' mature content. The biggest 'danger' here is a bruised ego or a friendship spat, which is exactly what the target audience is dealing with in real life.

Enriching

High marks for social-emotional learning. It teaches kids about 'social math'—how to manage expectations, how to host guests, and why trying to be 'cool' usually backfires. It’s a masterclass in empathy for the middle-school set.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The graphic novel format (adapted by Ellen T. Crenshaw) is visually engaging and perfect for kids who find traditional novels a bit of a slog.
It tackles a very specific, relatable anxiety: what happens when your 'old' friends meet your 'new' friends.
The New York City backdrop is a fun departure from the usual Stoneybrook setting, giving the story a faster, more sophisticated energy.
It doesn't sugarcoat the fact that Stacey is kind of the 'villain' of her own story for a bit, which is a great lesson in self-awareness.

⚠

What to Watch For

Stacey's NYC friends are intentionally snobbish and 'sophisticated,' which might be annoying for some readers.
There’s some minor 'mean girl' behavior and social exclusion, but it’s addressed and resolved by the end.

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Stacey felt like she had to act differently when she was with her New York friends?"
"Have you ever felt caught between two different groups of friends who didn't really like each other?"
"What would you do if you planned a big trip and everything started going wrong immediately?"
"Is it possible to outgrow a place or a person, or do people just change?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic