Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Look, if you’re looking for the bright, quippy Peter Parker from the MCU, this isn't it. This is the 1990s 'adjectiveless' Spider-Man run where Todd McFarlane was given the keys to the kingdom and decided to turn the lights off.
The art is the star here. It’s gorgeous, detailed, and dynamic in a way that still holds up in 2026. However, the story is grim. It starts with Spidey being hunted through the sewers by a bloodthirsty Lizard and only gets darker from there.
It’s a foundational piece of comic history, but it’s definitely for the older kids who can handle some 'grim and gritty' storytelling. It’s not boring, but the writing is definitely a product of its era—lots of words to say 'I am very sad and tired.'
Age Fit
Best for ages 12 and up. It’s perfect for the middle schooler who wants to read something that feels 'edgy' without being full-blown adult content. If your kid still thinks Spider-Man is just for toddlers, this will be a reality check.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
42
This isn't the 'friendly neighborhood' vibe. It's intentionally dark, moody, and centers on Peter Parker's internal torment and brutal physical struggles.
Imaginative
94
Todd McFarlane’s art redefined the medium. The way he draws movement and those iconic 'spaghetti webs' is a masterclass in visual creativity.
Safe
62
It's a book, so no digital risks, but the content is heavy. We’re talking 'streets run red with blood' and homicidal rampages. Not for the 'Spidey and His Amazing Friends' crowd.
Enriching
58
Maintains the core 'responsibility' theme of Spider-Man, but focuses more on the visceral, gritty experience of being a hero than on deep moral complexity.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
The art is legendary and essentially invented the modern visual language of Spider-Man.
It’s a great 'bridge' book for kids moving from standard superhero stories to more mature graphic novels.
Features epic team-ups with Ghost Rider, Wolverine, and X-Force that feel high-stakes and cinematic.
⚠
What to Watch For
The 'Torment' arc is surprisingly bloody and features a feral, cannibalistic version of the Lizard.
McFarlane’s writing is very much of its time—expect a lot of heavy, angsty internal monologue that might feel clunky to modern readers.
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think the artist chose to make the webs look so messy and tangled compared to older comics?"
"Spider-Man is usually joking around; why do you think he’s so serious and dark in this specific story?"
"When the Lizard loses his humanity, is he still responsible for his actions, or is he just an animal?"