2024, Young Adult Fiction
WISE Score
A beekeeper's daughter in an isolated town faces sinister forest creatures who grant secret wishes for deadly favors.
Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Erin A. Craig's Small Favors is a slow-burning folk horror novel that trades bright YA tropes for grim temptations and forest monsters.
If your teen loved House of Salt and Sorrows or stories where a town's own secret greed does half the monster's work, this delivers a eerie atmosphere. Skip it for middle schoolers or sensitive readers who aren't ready for bloody bargains and mounting psychological dread.
Best for readers 14 and up who want genuine folk horror and dark fantasy rather than a light fairy tale.
It's a grim, atmosphere-heavy folk horror novel centered on sinister bargains, deceit, paranoia, and a town turning on itself.
Rich world-building weaves beekeeping lore, isolation, creeping forest monsters, and dark fairy-tale bargains into a distinct atmosphere.
Contains unsettling creature violence, body horror details, animal death, and intense psychological dread suited for teens rather than younger readers.
Offers sharp commentary on human greed, the danger of 'quick fixes,' and how easily fear and selfishness break down a community.
Small Favors works because it takes its time establishing Amity Falls before letting the monsters dismantle it. Ellerie Downing's life revolves around her family's beehives, winter preparations, and the unspoken rules of a settlement pinned against an impenetrable forest. When supply runs fail and strange things start happening, the threat isn't just what's hiding in the trees; it's what her neighbors are willing to trade away for personal relief.
The novel functions as a dark cautionary tale about shortcut solutions. The creatures offering 'small favors' operate like classic fairy-tale tricksters, granting immediate wishes while quietly collecting debts that tear the town apart from the inside.
For teen readers, the horror is active and atmospheric rather than gratuitously shock-driven, though the violence ramps up significantly in the final act. It's a solid choice for young adults who enjoy historical fantasy with genuine teeth.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
