Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a solid, comforting read for the kid who's not the star athlete, not the math whiz, not the class clown—just trying to figure out where they belong. Grabenstein nails the middle school feeling of being surrounded by people who seem to have it all figured out while you're still searching.
The astronomy angle is a nice hook, and the inclusion of a science experiment shows thoughtfulness. It's not groundbreaking, but it's warm, funny, and genuinely affirming for kids who need to hear that 'shining' doesn't always look like winning trophies or getting straight A's.
A great pick for a kid going through a transition (new school, new friend group) or anyone who's ever felt like they're just... fine. Which is most of us, honestly.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 8-12, especially kids in the thick of middle school social dynamics or feeling like they're still figuring out who they are. The themes are too nuanced for younger readers, and teens will likely have aged out of the middle-grade voice.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
A warm middle-grade story about finding your place and self-worth. Centers on a girl navigating the classic fish-out-of-water experience at a new school where everyone seems to excel at something. Models persistence, self-discovery, and the reality that not everyone is 'born to shine' in obvious ways—which is actually a healthy, grounded message for kids who feel average. The humor and heart keep it from being preachy.
Imaginative
72
The astronomy/space science angle (inspired by a TV host character) adds a curiosity-sparking element, and the book includes a bonus science experiment. But this is fundamentally a realistic middle school story, not a high-concept adventure. It invites kids to think about identity and potential, but doesn't push boundaries in terms of world-building or creative expression.
Safe
95
Classic middle-grade territory from Chris Grabenstein, a well-known children's author. No content warnings, no mature themes. The conflict is social/emotional (fitting in, self-doubt), not violent or traumatic. Books are generally safe, and this one is textbook appropriate for its audience.
Enriching
80
Tackles real middle school anxieties—feeling ordinary, imposter syndrome at a fancy school, comparing yourself to peers who seem naturally gifted. The science tie-in (astronomy, a female role model in STEM) adds educational value. Strong Amazon rating (4.7) suggests it resonates with readers. The 'big questions' about identity and belonging offer meaningful takeaways beyond entertainment.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Validates kids who feel average or haven't found their 'thing' yet—a refreshing counter to the 'everyone's special' narrative
Astronomy and STEM woven in naturally through a cool female role model character (astronaut/TV host)
Chris Grabenstein brings his signature humor and heart; high Amazon rating suggests it connects with readers
Includes a bonus science experiment, which is a nice touch for hands-on learners
Tackles imposter syndrome and social anxiety in a relatable, non-preachy way
⚠
What to Watch For
Some kids might find the 'posh private school' setting hard to relate to if they're not in that world
The pacing is gentle—this isn't a high-stakes adventure, so action-hungry readers might get restless
Self-doubt is a central theme, which could resonate deeply or feel a bit heavy depending on your kid's headspace
Conversation Starters
"Piper feels like she doesn't fit in at her new school. Have you ever felt that way? What helped?"
"Everyone at Chumley Prep seems to be 'the best' at something. Do you think people are born with talents, or do they develop them?"
"If you could meet an astronaut or scientist like Nellie Dumont Frisse, what would you ask them?"
"What's something you're curious about that you'd want to explore more—like Piper with astronomy?"
