Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
If your teen loves high-stakes fantasy romance, Serpent & Dove delivers every beloved trope in spades. Shelby Mahurin takes forced marriage, secret identities, and a witch-hunting captain married to a hidden witch, then turns up the tension. It is fast, witty, and deeply entertaining for mature readers.
Do not let the Young Adult label deceive you into buying this for a middle schooler expecting a cozy magic story. The book features graphic public burnings, blood magic, and an explicit sex scene that lands it firmly in 15+ territory.
Age Fit
Firmly for readers aged 15 and up. While marketed under the Young Adult umbrella, the explicit sexual content, witch burnings, and graphic violence make this a New Adult crossover.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
28
Deals heavily with religious fanaticism, witch burnings, human sacrifice, deception, and systemic execution, alongside explicit sexual content.
Imaginative
82
Rich French-inspired fantasy world with a distinct magic system based on balance and sacrifice, paired with sharp character dynamics.
Safe
32
Contains explicit sexual scenes, graphic violence, torture, beheadings, and witch burnings that make it unsuitable for younger teens expecting standard YA.
Enriching
68
Offers meaningful reflections on unlearning fanatical bias, questioning authority, and agency, though wrapped in high-drama romance tropes.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Addictive tropes executed well — Enemies-to-lovers, forced marriage, and secret identity dynamics keep the pacing fast.
Sharp, funny protagonist — Lou is an unapologetic thief who uses wit and practical survival instincts rather than acting like a passive victim.
Explores systemic indoctrination — Deals directly with how fear, institutional dogmatism, and religious extremism fuel hatred.
⚠
What to Watch For
Explicit sexual content — Crosses into New Adult territory with a detailed, explicit sex scene in Chapter 40.
Graphic violence — Features depictions of witch burnings, public beheadings, torture, and blood sacrifices.
Dark themes & profanity — Heavy focus on genocide, parental abuse, and religious persecution, backed by frequent strong language.
Conversation Starters
"Reid spent his whole life believing witches were irredeemable monsters. What made him start questioning that dogma?"
"Lou had to conceal her identity to survive. Where do you draw the line between necessary self-preservation and destructive deception?"
"How does the book show the danger of black-and-white thinking in a society?"
Deep Dive
The Crossover Era of Fantasy Romance
Serpent & Dove sits squarely in the modern 'romantasy' boom. Shelby Mahurin blends French-flavored historical aesthetics with intense character conflict. The plot hinges on the volatile chemistry between Louise le Blanc, a runaway witch hiding in the city of Cesarine, and Reid Diggory, a zealous captain in the Chasseurs who hunts and burns witches.
When a public mess forces them into a shotgun marriage, the narrative leans into the classic forced-proximity setup. Lou's irreverent humor balances Reid's rigid, self-righteous worldview, making their banter one of the strongest elements of the book.
Content Friction Points for Families
While shelved in the YA section, the boundary between YA and New Adult is thin here:
Romance & Sex: The romantic tension culminates in an explicit scene late in the story detailing physical intimacy.
Violence & Horror: The Church's crusade is brutal. Expect descriptions of public burnings at the stake, beheadings, torture, and blood sacrifice.
Thematic Weight: The primary themes deal with religious fanaticism, institutional trauma, and unlearning deep-seated prejudice.
For 15- and 16-year-olds who enjoy authors like Sarah J. Maas or Holly Black, Serpent & Dove hits the mark. Keep it away from younger kids who aren't ready for explicit content.
