Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the thing: Saving Mr. Banks is a genuinely good movie. Well-acted, thoughtfully structured, emotionally resonant for adults who appreciate the Mary Poppins legacy and understand creative tension. The problem? Most kids—even teenagers—will find it deadly dull.

This is a talky, slow-paced biographical drama about contract negotiations, creative control, and processing childhood trauma through art. Those are sophisticated themes that require patience and emotional maturity to appreciate. The flashbacks to P.L. Travers' difficult childhood are beautifully done but heavy—her father's alcoholism and death aren't sugar-coated.

If you've got a 13-15 year old who loves behind-the-scenes content, wants to be a filmmaker, or is genuinely curious about how movies get made, this could be a great watch-together experience. But for the average tween or teen? They're going to be wondering when something is actually going to happen. It's a movie about meetings and memories, not magic and adventure.

The WISE fundamentals are solid—it's wholesome in its treatment of difficult subjects, enriching for the right audience, and safe aside from emotional heaviness. But the entertainment factor for modern kids is limited. This is one for families who prioritize film literacy and don't mind slower pacing, not for Friday night pizza-and-movie crowds.

Age Fit

Best for ages 13-16 who have a genuine interest in film history, creative process, or literary adaptation. Younger kids will be bored; older teens might find it a bit too earnest and slow unless they're film buffs.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

78

A thoughtful biographical drama that models persistence, creative collaboration, and reconciliation. The film explores difficult childhood trauma (alcoholism, family instability) with emotional honesty but handles it maturely. Shows respect between characters even when they disagree, and ultimately models forgiveness and understanding. The pacing is deliberate rather than chaotic, appropriate for the subject matter.

Imaginative

72

Behind-the-scenes look at the creative process of making Mary Poppins offers interesting insight into how stories are adapted and how personal experiences shape art. The dual timeline structure showing P.L. Travers' childhood alongside the 1960s production meetings is creative storytelling. However, it's more about observing creativity than actively inspiring it—this is a movie about making a movie, not one that directly sparks imaginative play or exploration.

Safe

68

Common Sense Media rates it 13+, which is appropriate. Contains emotionally heavy flashback sequences dealing with alcoholism, parental illness, and implied suicide (father's death from TB complicated by drinking). No violence, gore, nudity, or sex, but the emotional weight of childhood trauma and a parent's deterioration could be unexpectedly intense for younger viewers. Some period-appropriate smoking. The difficult content is handled sensitively but is definitely present and could be triggering.

Enriching

75

Strong scores across review aggregates (79% RT critics, 84% audience, 7.5 IMDb) indicate quality storytelling. Offers insight into creative process, adaptation challenges, and how childhood experiences shape adult perspectives. Explores themes of control, grief, and letting go. The historical context of 1960s Hollywood and Walt Disney's approach to filmmaking provides educational value. However, it's a fairly niche interest—most kids won't be fascinated by the business of movie-making or literary adaptation rights.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Fascinating peek behind the curtain at how a beloved classic got made, with all the creative conflict and compromise that entails
Emma Thompson and Tom Hanks deliver excellent performances that show how adults navigate disagreement with professionalism
Explores how childhood trauma shapes adult behavior and the power of storytelling as both protection and healing
Great for kids interested in writing, filmmaking, or understanding how personal experiences become art
Historical snapshot of 1960s Hollywood and Walt Disney's creative empire

⚠

What to Watch For

Flashback sequences showing a father's alcoholism and decline are emotionally intense—not graphic, but genuinely sad
This is a slow-burn adult drama about creative negotiations and childhood grief, not a kids' movie despite the Disney connection
The pacing is deliberate and dialogue-heavy; younger viewers will likely lose interest quickly
Some smoking (period-appropriate) and brief mild language

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think P.L. Travers was so protective of her Mary Poppins character? What does the story mean to her?"
"Have you ever created something (a story, drawing, project) that felt really personal? How would you feel if someone wanted to change it?"
"The movie shows how childhood experiences shaped the Mary Poppins books. What experiences or memories might you want to turn into a story someday?"
"Walt Disney kept trying for 20 years to get the rights to Mary Poppins. When is persistence admirable versus pushy?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Mary Poppins: A Parent's Guide to Magic and Modern Context

From its 2024 rating update to timeless lessons on imagination, here’s how to revisit the 1964 Disney classic with your kids.

Writing about Saving Mr. Banks? Put this WISE score on your site