Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a genuinely clever picture book that works on multiple levels. Young kids see two boys digging a hole with their dog—simple, fun, relatable. Older kids and adults catch the visual irony and appreciate the deadpan humor.
The Klassen illustrations are doing serious heavy lifting here, showing readers the enormous treasures underground while Sam and Dave remain oblivious. It's funny, it's suspenseful, and it teaches kids to look closely at pictures, not just words.
The parallel-universe ending is either brilliant or confusing depending on your kid. Some will love puzzling it out; others will just be baffled. Either way, it's a quick read that might inspire some backyard excavation, which is never a bad thing.
Not life-changing, but solidly entertaining and smarter than your average picture book.
Age Fit
Best for ages 4-8. Younger kids will enjoy the simple story and digging adventure, while older kids will catch the visual jokes and puzzle over the parallel-universe twist. By 9 or 10, most kids will have aged out unless they're reading to younger siblings.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Two boys embark on a simple, wholesome backyard adventure with their dog. The story models persistence and optimism without conflict or negative behavior. The deadpan humor is gentle and age-appropriate, though the slightly surreal ending (they miss all the treasures underground and end up in a parallel universe) might confuse very young readers.
Imaginative
92
This is where the book truly shines. The visual storytelling by Caldecott Honor-winning Jon Klassen creates a delightful irony—readers see the enormous diamonds and fossils that Sam and Dave keep narrowly missing. The parallel universe twist at the end rewards attentive readers. It invites kids to look closely, predict, and think about what's happening beneath the surface. Inspires actual digging adventures and hide-and-seek games.
Safe
98
Completely safe. Two kids dig a hole in their backyard with a dog. No scary content, no violence, no inappropriate themes. One reviewer noted it's 'super creepy' but this appears to be about the subtle parallel-universe ending rather than anything genuinely frightening. The only minor concern is the slightly unsettling realization that they've ended up somewhere different, but it's handled with such lightness that it's barely noticeable.
Enriching
79
The book teaches visual literacy and close reading—kids must pay attention to the illustrations to understand the full story. It explores themes of perspective (what you see vs. what's really there), persistence, and finding wonder in unexpected places. Common Sense Media and parent reviews recommend pairing it with science activities about earth and minerals. However, it's primarily entertainment rather than deeply educational, and the abstract ending may leave some kids puzzled rather than enlightened.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
The visual irony is chef's kiss—kids see the massive diamonds Sam and Dave keep missing by inches, creating genuine suspense and humor
Caldecott Honor winner from the Mac Barnett/Jon Klassen dream team (same duo behind Extra Yarn and Triangle)
Teaches visual literacy and close reading without being preachy—the illustrations tell half the story
Inspires actual backyard adventures and discussions about persistence, perspective, and paying attention
The subtle parallel-universe ending gives older kids something to puzzle over and discuss
⚠
What to Watch For
The surreal ending (they end up in a slightly different world) might confuse or unsettle very young or literal-minded kids
Some kids may be frustrated that Sam and Dave never find the treasure—it's about the journey, not the destination
The deadpan, minimalist style won't work for every kid; some need more obvious excitement
Conversation Starters
"Did you notice all the treasure they missed? Why do you think they kept digging right past it?"
"At the end, what was different about their house? Do you think they're in the same place they started?"
"Have you ever looked really hard for something and missed it because you weren't looking in the right place?"
"If you could dig a hole in our backyard, what do you think you'd find?"