Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Let's be real: almost no modern teen is picking this up for fun. The language is genuinely hard, the pacing drags by today's standards, and the whole 'death as ultimate romance' thing is... a lot.

That said, if your kid is studying it for school, the Folger edition is your friend—those annotations actually help. And there's real value in understanding why this story has endured, even if the answer is partly 'because English teachers keep assigning it.'

The bigger issue is the content. Multiple deaths, a 13-year-old bride, and a suicide pact framed as romantic devotion need serious contextualization. This isn't a story that models healthy relationships or good decision-making—it's a cautionary tale that somehow got rebranded as the ultimate love story.

For high schoolers tackling it in class? Fine, with discussion. For independent reading? There are way more engaging ways to build literary skills. And if your middle schooler's teacher assigns it, maybe send a gentle email asking how they plan to frame the suicide content.

Age Fit

Best for ages 13+ in an academic context where teachers can provide framing and discussion. The language alone makes it nearly inaccessible for younger readers, and the suicide content requires maturity and adult guidance. This isn't pleasure reading for most teens—it's homework that can be meaningful with support.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

35

The story centers on secret teenage romance, family violence, multiple deaths including double suicide, and impulsive decisions driven by infatuation rather than healthy relationship modeling. While parental concern is shown, the overall emotional arc glorifies death as romantic union rather than modeling resilience or healthy conflict resolution.

Imaginative

78

Shakespeare's language is genuinely inventive and poetic, introducing readers to metaphor, wordplay, and dramatic structure that has influenced storytelling for centuries. The Folger edition includes scholarly notes that help unlock the linguistic creativity. However, the imagination required is more interpretive than generative—readers consume rather than create.

Safe

42

Contains multiple violent deaths (stabbing, poisoning, suicide), a 13-year-old girl pressured into marriage, sexual innuendo throughout, and a blood feud with graphic consequences. Common Sense Media notes the challenging content. While it's a classic text without gratuitous modern gore, the suicide pact and normalization of teen death as romantic is genuinely concerning content that requires framing.

Enriching

72

Undeniably important for literary education—introduces Shakespearean language, dramatic structure, and cultural literacy that appears everywhere from SATs to pop culture. The Folger edition's annotations and scholarly essay provide genuine learning scaffolding. Offers discussion opportunities about consequences, family conflict, and historical context. However, the 'enrichment' assumes a motivated reader willing to wrestle with archaic language.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The Folger edition is genuinely helpful with facing-page notes that decode the Elizabethan English without dumbing it down
Cultural literacy jackpot—references to this show up everywhere from SAT questions to Taylor Swift lyrics
Shakespeare's wordplay and metaphors are legitimately brilliant if you can crack the language code
Opens conversations about consequences, family conflict, and how storytelling has evolved over 400+ years
For teens studying it in school, having a well-annotated edition makes the assignment way less painful

⚠

What to Watch For

Double suicide ending—the lovers' deaths are framed as romantic and inevitable, which needs serious unpacking with teens
Juliet is 13 and being pressured into marriage; the age dynamics are historically accurate but deeply uncomfortable
Multiple violent deaths including stabbing and poisoning throughout the blood feud
The language barrier is real—even strong readers will need patience and probably some YouTube explainer videos
Kid reviews on Common Sense Media are mixed, with many calling the characters impulsive and the 'love' just infatuation

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think this story about teenagers making terrible decisions has lasted 400 years?"
"If Romeo and Juliet had cell phones, how would this story be different?"
"The families are fighting but nobody even remembers why—have you seen that happen in real life?"
"Do you think their love was real or just intense feelings? What's the difference?"
"Why do you think Shakespeare made them die instead of finding another ending?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Romeo and Juliet William Shakespeare? Put this WISE score on your site