Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This isn't a 'beach read.' It’s a heavy, emotional deep-dive into what happens when the people supposed to take care of you just... don't.
Deirdre Riordan Hall doesn't sugarcoat the reality of Pearl's life, which makes the eventual hope feel earned rather than cheap. If your teen is into gritty contemporary fiction or is an aspiring artist, this will resonate. It’s a solid 'read-together-and-discuss' pick for high schoolers.
Age Fit
Best for ages 14 and up. The themes of addiction and 'adult' responsibilities falling on a teenager make this a more mature read than your average middle-school novel.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72
While the backstory involves heavy themes like drug addiction and homelessness, the narrative arc is focused on healing, the power of art, and building healthy, trusting relationships.
Imaginative
65
The use of art as a metaphor for self-reconstruction is a nice touch, though the 'elite boarding school' setting is a well-worn trope in YA fiction.
Safe
60
It deals with gritty reality—specifically parental drug abuse and the trauma of homelessness. It's safe for its intended teen audience, but not a 'surprise' read for younger kids who aren't ready for heavy social issues.
Enriching
82
Excellent exploration of resilience and the conscious choice to break a cycle of family failure. It offers deep empathy for those in 'invisible' situations like teen homelessness.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
It treats teen homelessness with dignity rather than pity.
The focus on art as a tool for recovery provides a great creative hook.
Pearl’s journey toward 'courage over easy ways' is a powerful moral compass for older teens.
It avoids the 'magic fix' ending, acknowledging that trauma takes work to unpack.
⚠
What to Watch For
The mother's drug addiction is central to the plot and can be triggering or intense.
Descriptions of the instability and fear associated with being homeless.
The 'troubled art teacher' dynamic—it's handled well, but it's an intense emotional relationship.
Conversation Starters
"Pearl says she’s a 'replica' of her mother. Do you think we’re destined to repeat our parents' mistakes, or is that a choice?"
"Why do you think art helps Pearl express things she can't say out loud?"
"Grant shows Pearl what it means to trust. What are the 'green flags' you look for in a friend when things are going wrong?"