Is this just regular makeup?

Not really. While you can use it for daily looks, the 'Create Paints' are designed to be high-pigment liquids that dry down for intense color payoff, more like professional face paint than a standard blush or eyeshadow.

Why is James Charles controversial?

He has been at the center of multiple 'cancel culture' moments involving feuds with other influencers and, more seriously, allegations regarding inappropriate communication with minors. Most of this played out on YouTube and Twitter.

Is it safe for a 10-year-old?

Physically, yes, it's cosmetic-grade. Socially, a 10-year-old might stumble into a lot of mature internet 'tea' by searching for tutorials on how to use these products.

Painted – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Painted

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Product2023

75%

WISE Score

Face paints for the TikTok generation—high-pigment, high-skill, and tied to one of the internet’s most polarizing artists.

Painted

Product

2023

75%

WISE Score

Face paints for the TikTok generation—high-pigment, high-skill, and tied to one of the internet’s most polarizing artists.

Jump to

Where to Buy

Visit official site

Screenwise Verdict

Painted is a legit art tool masquerading as a makeup brand. If your kid is the type to spend three hours in front of a mirror turning themselves into a literal masterpiece, these paints are top-tier.

However, you can't talk about Painted without talking about James Charles. For many parents, his track record of internet drama and past allegations is a hard 'no' for their wallet. If you don't care about the personality behind the paint, the product itself is high-quality and creatively enriching.

Age Fit

This is for the 12+ crowd. Younger kids won't have the motor skills to use these effectively, and the brand context is heavily aimed at the teen/young adult influencer audience.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

While makeup artistry is a great outlet, the brand is inseparable from James Charles, whose career has been defined by high-octane internet drama and various controversies.

Imaginative

These aren't just 'cover-up' products; they are multi-use paints designed for transformative, high-concept art. It encourages kids to treat their face as a literal canvas.

Safe

The products themselves are standard cosmetic grade. The safety 'friction' comes from the gateway to James Charles' social media ecosystem, which has a history of boundary-pushing content and personal scandals.

Enriching

Teaches genuine technical skills like color theory, blending, and precision. It’s a step up from basic glitter and gloss into actual artistry.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Encourages genuine artistry and 'transformative' makeup over just standard beauty standards.
The 'Create Paints' are professional-grade, meaning they actually work for complex looks that cheaper kits can't handle.
Great for teens interested in special effects (SFX) or editorial makeup styles.
Focuses on the 'artist' aspect, which can be a healthy pivot from the vanity-focused side of the beauty industry.

⚠

What to Watch For

Buying these is a direct endorsement of James Charles; if you've opted out of his specific brand of influencer culture, this is the front door.
The price point is 'prosumer'—it’s an investment, not a stocking stuffer for a casual user.
High learning curve: these are literal paints, and without some YouTube tutorial guidance, they can be messy and frustrating.

Conversation Starters

"What’s the difference between using makeup to 'fix' your face versus using it to create art?"
"How do you feel about supporting creators who have had major public controversies?"
"If you could paint any character or look on your face, what would be the hardest part to get right?"

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

James Charles: Makeup, Meltdowns, and Why the ‘Sisters’ are Still Watching

He’s been ‘canceled’ for everything from sexting scandals to mocking laid-off workers, but he remains a fixture for the middle school set.

Writing about Painted? Put this WISE score on your site