Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. As an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns from qualifying purchases, so if you buy a book or game through one of our links, we may earn a commission. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)
Screenwise Verdict
Look, as a piece of kitschy nostalgia, this is a fun $15 purchase to play once or twice for the laughs. As an actual game? It's pretty terrible.
It captures the 'you have died' spirit of the original computer game a little too well, meaning it's almost entirely based on luck. You'll draw a card, you'll die, and you'll write a name on a tombstone. If you want a solid family game night, there are a hundred better cooperative games (like Forbidden Island). If you want to laugh at how unfair life was in the 19th century while drinking a beer or a soda, this works fine.
Age Fit
The box says 12+, but an 8-year-old can easily understand the rules. The real question is whether they have the emotional maturity to handle a game that is designed to make them lose constantly.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72
It's a cooperative experience where players have to work together to survive, though the 'wholesomeness' is undercut by the fact that the game's primary mechanic is watching your friends die of dysentery.
Imaginative
55
It leans heavily on 8-bit nostalgia rather than true creative exploration. The most 'imaginative' part is writing funny epitaphs on the dry-erase tombstones.
Safe
98
Extremely safe. The 'violence' is text-based and historical (snake bites, exhaustion). No mature themes, gambling, or social risks.
Enriching
50
While it touches on American history, the gameplay is too random to teach real resource management or strategy. It's more of a 'luck of the draw' simulator than an educational tool.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Hits the nostalgia button hard for parents who grew up with the Apple IIe version
Cooperative gameplay means the family loses together instead of fighting each other
Writing epitaphs on the tombstones is a genuine highlight
Very easy to learn and get to the table quickly
⚠
What to Watch For
The game is notoriously 'broken'—you can lose on the first turn through no fault of your own
High randomness can be incredibly frustrating for kids who like to feel in control
Components like the cards and the 'rounded' die are a bit cheap and flimsy
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think families took such a dangerous risk to move West?"
"If we were actually on the trail, what one supply would you refuse to leave behind?"
"Is it fair that the game kills you off just because of a bad card draw? How does that compare to real life for pioneers?"