Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
If you’re looking for your next 'can't-stop-reading-until-2am' book, this is it. Lisa Jewell has moved past simple mysteries into something much more clinical and creepy. It’s the perfect read for parents who need an escape—just know that the 'escape' involves some of the most uncomfortable domestic situations imaginable.
For the family library, keep this one on the high shelf. It’s not that it’s 'explicit' in a trashy way, but the psychological darkness is intense. It’s a great pick for a book club where you want to argue about who was actually the villain.
Age Fit
This is strictly for adults and perhaps very mature older teens (17+). The themes of domestic abuse and predatory behavior are handled with weight, but they are extremely heavy and inappropriate for younger readers.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
15
This is a dark psychological thriller centered on manipulation, domestic abuse, and toxic family dynamics. It is the opposite of 'feel-good' content.
Imaginative
82
Lisa Jewell uses a clever 'story within a story' structure, incorporating podcast transcripts and Netflix documentary snippets to keep the reader guessing.
Safe
25
Contains heavy themes of grooming, pedophilia, domestic violence, and psychological torture. Not a book to leave lying around for a curious middle-schooler.
Enriching
68
It offers a sharp, cynical look at the ethics of the true crime industry and how podcasters can exploit trauma for downloads.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Masterful pacing that makes it almost impossible to put down once the podcast starts recording.
The meta-narrative structure uses 'transcripts' and 'interviews' to give you a 360-degree view of the train wreck.
It's a sharp critique of our cultural obsession with true crime and the people who profit from it.
Genuinely unsettling atmosphere that stays with you long after the final page.
⚠
What to Watch For
The plot involves disturbing grooming and pedophilia themes that are central to the 'villain's' backstory.
It’s an unreliable narrator feast; if your teen reads this, they might need a debrief on how manipulation works in real-time.
The ending is intentionally ambiguous, which might frustrate anyone looking for a clean 'good guys win' resolution.
Conversation Starters
"Does the true crime industry do more harm than good for the victims involved?"
"Why are we so drawn to 'unreliable narrators' in books and movies?"
"At what point does Alix's ambition cross the line into negligence?"
"How does the book change your perspective on the 'perfect' families we see on social media?"