This is one of the better middle-grade books tackling 9/11, which is both a compliment and a warning. It's thoughtful, empathetic, and age-appropriate without being sanitized. The parallel narrative structure works, and the diverse perspectives—especially Naheed's experience as a Muslim girl—are handled with care.

But let's be clear: this is a book about a national tragedy. Even though it focuses on the days before the attacks, readers know what's coming, and that creates a sense of dread throughout. It's enriching and important, but it's not light reading.

For kids who need to understand 9/11 (and honestly, most middle schoolers do), this is a solid choice. It makes history personal without being exploitative. Just be ready for some heavy conversations afterward.