New Rockstars – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

New Rockstars

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

YouTube2011

79%

WISE Score

4.3M

Subscribers

The ultimate 'wait, did you see that?' deep dive for every fan who needs to know what that one background pixel means for the future of the multiverse.

New Rockstars

YouTube

2011

79%

WISE Score

4.3M

Subscribers

The ultimate 'wait, did you see that?' deep dive for every fan who needs to know what that one background pixel means for the future of the multiverse.

Jump to

Also rated on

4.3M

Screenwise Verdict

New Rockstars is the 'smart' side of YouTube. It’s essentially an English Literature class disguised as superhero hype. Hosted by the incredibly sharp Erik Voss, it transforms passive screen time into an exercise in observation and theory-crafting.

However, it’s not a 'set it and forget it' channel. Because they cover everything in pop culture, a kid watching a clean Spider-Man breakdown is only one click away from a breakdown of The Boys featuring significantly more blood and adult language. If your kid is a Marvel or Star Wars obsessive, this is great fuel for their brain, provided you've set some ground rules about which 'universes' they're allowed to explore.

Age Fit

Best for ages 10 and up. Younger kids won't have the attention span for 25-minute frame-by-frame breakdowns, and the occasional clips from R-rated shows like The Boys make it a 'watch-with-them' situation for middle schoolers.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The tone is enthusiastically nerdy and professional. While they discuss mature franchises, the hosts themselves model articulate, respectful discourse and genuine passion for storytelling.

Imaginative

This is the peak of 'theory-crafting.' It encourages viewers to look beyond the surface, connect dots across different media, and imagine 'what if' scenarios based on deep lore.

Safe

While the hosts are 'clean,' the channel frequently breaks down TV-MA and R-rated content (The Boys, Game of Thrones, Deadpool). Clips of gore, violence, or mature themes from those properties appear in the analysis.

Enriching

It's essentially a masterclass in media literacy. It teaches kids to notice cinematography, narrative structure, and thematic callbacks, turning passive viewing into active analysis.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Media Literacy 101: It teaches kids how to actually watch a movie, noticing lighting, framing, and narrative callbacks rather than just zoning out.
Deep Lore Mastery: For fans of Marvel or Star Wars, this is the gold standard for understanding the complex world-building of their favorite franchises.
Critical Thinking: The 'theory' videos encourage viewers to build their own logical arguments based on evidence found in the source material.
High Production Value: Unlike many 'reaction' channels, this is scripted, researched, and professionally edited analysis.

⚠

What to Watch For

The 'Boys' Problem: They do deep dives into The Boys and Invincible. These videos contain clips of extreme gore and adult themes that aren't suitable for younger kids, even if the Marvel videos are fine.
Spoiler Minefield: If your kid hasn't seen the latest blockbuster on opening night, they need to stay off this channel. The thumbnails and titles are often massive spoilers.
The Infinite Loop: The 'theory' nature of the content can make kids feel like they must watch every breakdown to stay 'current' with a fandom, feeding into YouTube's engagement traps.

Conversation Starters

"Which of Erik's theories do you actually think will come true, and why?"
"Did you notice that Easter egg when we watched the movie, or did they have to point it out?"
"Why do you think the directors put that specific detail in the background?"
"Do you think knowing all the 'behind the scenes' stuff makes the movie more or less fun to watch?"