Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Look, NCIS: New Orleans is the TV equivalent of beige wallpaper. It's not offensive, it's not terrible, but it's also not particularly good or memorable. The 6.8 IMDb and 55 Metacritic scores tell the real story: critics found it bland, audiences found it watchable-ish.

The New Orleans setting should have made this interesting—jazz, food, unique culture—but it mostly just serves as backdrop for the same formulaic crime-solving you get in every NCIS iteration. Episode structure: crime happens, team investigates, red herrings, solve case, repeat.

For teens 14+ who specifically want crime procedurals, it's fine. It's network TV safe, meaning no graphic gore or sexual content. But let's be real: in 2025, this show feels dated and slow. There are so many better options for mystery-loving teens that actually have character development, stakes, or creativity.

If your kid wants crime shows, steer them toward something with more substance. This is background noise TV that parents might have on while folding laundry, not appointment viewing for anyone.

Age Fit

Common Sense Media's 14+ rating is spot-on—the crime content is too heavy for younger kids, but teens who like procedurals might tolerate it. That said, even teens would probably rather watch something with actual stakes or character development.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

Standard procedural crime drama with team camaraderie and cooperation. Models professional teamwork and justice-seeking, though crime content means emotional tone skews darker. Pacing is episodic and predictable rather than chaotic, but the constant parade of murders and investigations isn't exactly warm and fuzzy.

Imaginative

42

This is a paint-by-numbers procedural that follows the NCIS formula with a New Orleans backdrop. The jazz music and Louisiana culture add some flavor, but it's fundamentally a case-of-the-week format with minimal creative spark. No invitation to build, explore, or express creativity—just passive viewing of formulaic crime-solving.

Safe

58

Crime procedural means every episode involves murder, violence, and dead bodies. While not graphically gory by cable standards, there are crime scenes, weapons, and threat scenarios throughout. Common Sense Media rates it 14+, which tracks—younger kids would find the content disturbing. No sexual content or nudity typical of network TV, but the violence is consistent and central to every episode.

Enriching

52

Offers some insight into criminal investigation procedures and showcases New Orleans culture and history. The problem-solving aspect has mild cognitive value, and there's occasional ethical discussion about justice. But mostly it's entertainment without much depth—the cases wrap up neatly in 42 minutes with little lasting impact or meaningful growth opportunities.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Showcases New Orleans culture, music, and atmosphere if your kid is into Louisiana history
Models professional teamwork and procedural problem-solving in a law enforcement context
Safe network TV option for teens who want crime shows without graphic cable violence
Episodic format means you can drop in anywhere without commitment—also means zero stakes

⚠

What to Watch For

Every episode centers on murder and crime investigation—dead bodies, weapons, and violence are the entire premise
It's aggressively mediocre: a 6.8 IMDb and 55 Metacritic tell you everything about its 'meh' factor
Dated production values and formulaic plots make it tough for modern kids to stay engaged
The New Orleans setting is window dressing on a very standard procedural—don't expect actual cultural depth

Conversation Starters

"What did you think about how they solved the case? Could you have figured it out?"
"How realistic do you think this show is compared to actual police work?"
"What's interesting about New Orleans as a setting? Did you learn anything about the city?"

Stills