Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Mo Willems is the GOAT of modern picture books for a reason. While his other work like 'Elephant & Piggie' handles social dynamics, this one is all about the internal struggle of being small and wanting things NOW.
The visual style is a standout—it looks like a craft project come to life, which might actually inspire your kid to put down the iPad and grab some cardboard. It’s a high-quality, zero-stress read that respects a kid's perspective without being preachy. If you’re tired of reading the same boring bedtime stories, this one is a genuine treat for the parent too.
Age Fit
Ideal for the 3–7 crowd. It’s simple enough for a toddler to follow the rhythm, but the humor and 'guilt' theme resonate with early elementary kids.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
96
It centers on a warm, forgiving parent-child relationship. When Nanette fails her 'mission,' her mother meets her with empathy rather than anger, modeling a healthy way to handle mistakes.
Imaginative
92
Mo Willems built entire 3D cardboard dioramas of a French village to photograph as backgrounds. It’s visually distinct and practically begs kids to go build their own worlds out of cereal boxes.
Safe
100
Zero safety concerns. It’s a gentle story about a frog and some bread. No scary elements, no hidden mature themes.
Enriching
88
The wordplay and internal rhymes are fantastic for early literacy. It also gives kids a safe space to talk about impulse control and the 'heavy' feeling of making a mistake.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
The rhyming is incredibly clever and satisfying to read aloud—it never feels clunky or forced.
The artwork is unique; Willems built handcrafted cardboard sets, giving the book a tactile, 'maker' vibe.
It perfectly captures the 'marshmallow test' struggle of being a kid with zero impulse control.
The ending focuses on forgiveness and moving forward, which is a great emotional beat for toddlers.
⚠
What to Watch For
The 'reset' (upset) sequence gets a little dramatic, but it's handled with humor.
Expect an immediate and non-negotiable request for a baguette as soon as you close the book.
Conversation Starters
"What’s something you really want to do all by yourself, like Nanette did?"
"Why do you think it was so hard for Nanette to stop eating the warm bread?"
"How did Nanette feel after the baguette was gone? Have you ever felt that way?"
"What did Mom do when she saw Nanette was upset? Why didn't she get mad?"