Mystery Recipe – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Mystery Recipe

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

podcast

89%

WISE Score

A delightfully weird cooking podcast where kids learn food science, play games, and race to guess the mystery recipe before the big cook-along reveal.

Mystery Recipe

podcast

Clean

89%

WISE Score

A delightfully weird cooking podcast where kids learn food science, play games, and race to guess the mystery recipe before the big cook-along reveal.

Jump to

Also rated on

Screenwise Verdict

This is one of those rare kids podcasts that delivers exactly what it promises without being annoying to adults. Host Molly Birnbaum keeps the energy playful but not manic, and the educational content feels organic rather than forced.

The format is smart: each episode explores one ingredient through games, facts, and kid interviews before building to the mystery recipe reveal and cook-along. Parents report their kids actually retain the information and get genuinely excited about cooking—which is saying something in the age of Roblox and YouTube.

The only 'downside' is that it creates work for you: kids will want to cook the recipes, which means grocery shopping, kitchen supervision, and inevitable messes. But if you're looking for screen-free family time that's actually educational and fun, this is a winner. Way better than another hour of Bluey reruns.

Age Fit

Aimed at roughly 5-10 year olds, though younger kids will enjoy listening and older kids who like cooking will still find it engaging. The sweet spot is elementary schoolers who can help in the kitchen with supervision.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Models positive social skills through silly wordplay and cooperative interactions. Features kid guest hosts and encourages family cooking together. Common Sense Media confirms characters engage in playful, age-appropriate banter without meanness or chaos.

Imaginative

Each episode builds mystery and anticipation around ingredient exploration, culminating in a hands-on cook-along. Blends 'fun, fantastical, and fascinating' food facts with games and storytelling. Invites kids to experiment in the kitchen—a genuinely creative, multisensory activity.

Safe

Zero content concerns for audio podcasts aimed at kids. No mature themes, explicit language, or triggering material. Produced by America's Test Kitchen Kids, a reputable educational brand. Safe to play in the car or around the house without worry.

Enriching

Genuinely educational without feeling like homework—kids learn ingredient origins, food science, and cooking techniques. Parent reviews on Common Sense Media highlight that kids absorb information while having fun. Builds practical life skills and curiosity about food culture.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Actually makes kids excited about cooking and trying new ingredients—parent reviews confirm kids beg to make the recipes
Educational without being preachy: food history, science, and culture woven into silly games and wordplay
Kid guest hosts keep it relatable and fun, not just adults talking down to children
Perfect car ride entertainment that leads to real kitchen time together
From America's Test Kitchen Kids, so the recipes actually work and the information is solid

⚠

What to Watch For

You'll need to actually cook with them—this podcast creates expectations and excitement for hands-on kitchen time
Episodes work best when you can follow along with ingredients, so plan ahead or save for grocery shopping day
Might inspire requests for unusual ingredients or recipes outside your comfort zone

Conversation Starters

"What do you think the mystery ingredient is? Want to guess before they reveal it?"
"Should we try making this recipe this weekend? What sounds good to you?"
"What's the weirdest food fact you learned today? Want to test it out?"
"If you could invent a mystery recipe episode, what ingredient would you pick?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic