Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

This is what you put on when your 10-year-old wants to watch something 'cool' but you're not ready to hand them the Stranger Things remote. It's harmless, occasionally amusing, and completely forgettable—which is both its strength and weakness.

The vampire babysitter premise had potential, but this is very much a product of early 2010s Disney Channel factory production. The acting is serviceable, the effects are cheap, and the humor is... well, it's there. IMDb's 7.1 suggests the target demographic enjoyed it well enough, which tracks—kids in 2011 probably had a blast.

The problem is we're not in 2011 anymore. The show feels dated in ways that make it hard to recommend enthusiastically. The pacing, the jokes, the whole vibe screams 'before streaming changed everything.' Modern kids raised on higher-budget Netflix shows and YouTube content may find this painfully corny.

That said, if your kid is in that sweet spot where they want spooky content but you're not ready for actual horror, this could work. It's safe, it won't give anyone nightmares, and it models decent friendship. Just don't expect them to binge it or ask for a rewatch. It's background noise that keeps them entertained for 22 minutes while you make dinner.

Age Fit

Squarely aimed at the 9-12 crowd who want something 'edgier' than pure kids' content but aren't ready for actual teen drama. Older kids will find it babyish, younger kids might find the vampire stuff a bit much.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Canadian Disney Channel series that follows a wholesome teen comedy formula with supernatural elements. Models friendship and teamwork between the main characters (Ethan, Benny, and Sarah the vampire babysitter). The show has a generally positive tone with humor aimed at tweens, though it does include typical teen crushes and social dynamics. Common Sense Media's age 10 rating suggests age-appropriate content without mature themes.

Imaginative

68

Blends vampire mythology with suburban teen life in a creative premise. The show incorporates various supernatural creatures and magic alongside everyday middle school scenarios. However, it's working within well-worn Disney Channel formula territory—the imaginative premise doesn't necessarily translate to deeply original storytelling or creative inspiration for viewers. It's more 'fun concept' than truly inventive.

Safe

78

Designed for Disney Channel/family viewing with supernatural horror-comedy elements that are played for laughs rather than scares. The vampire and monster content is campy and age-appropriate for the Common Sense Media age 10 recommendation. Some mild peril and spooky scenarios, but nothing graphic or traumatizing. Kids mode available on streaming suggests platform considers it child-safe. No concerning content flags in available data.

Enriching

52

Primarily entertainment-focused with limited educational or developmental value. While it shows friendship dynamics and problem-solving, it's standard Disney Channel fare without much depth. The IMDb 7.1 rating suggests it's competently made and enjoyable for its target audience, but there's minimal cognitive growth, skill-building, or meaningful takeaways beyond basic 'friends work together' messaging. It's cotton candy—fun, not nutritious.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Safe supernatural fun for kids who want 'scary' content without actual scares—vampires are more goofy than menacing
Positive friendship dynamics between the main trio who solve problems together
Good starter show for kids interested in fantasy/supernatural genres before they're ready for darker content
Campy humor and self-aware tone that doesn't take itself too seriously

⚠

What to Watch For

Very 2011 aesthetic and humor—think early smartphone era Disney Channel with all the dated references and production values
Mild vampire/monster peril that's played for laughs but might startle younger or sensitive kids
Pretty shallow entertainment without much substance—it's junk food TV
May not hold the attention of kids used to higher-production streaming content

Conversation Starters

"If you could have any supernatural power like the characters, what would you choose and why?"
"The show makes vampires funny instead of scary—what other 'scary' things do you think could actually be silly?"
"How do Ethan and Benny stay friends even when they disagree about how to handle problems?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

My Babysitter's a Vampire