Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.

Screenwise Verdict

This is exactly what middle grade mystery should be: smart kids solving real problems, strong friendship, and enough intrigue to keep pages turning. The 1930s boarding school setting gives it a classic feel without being stuffy, and Hazel's experience as a Chinese student adds important depth and representation.

The murder element is handled perfectly for the age group—mysterious and compelling without being traumatic or graphic. It's cozy British crime for kids, think Agatha Christie lite. The Sherlock-Watson dynamic between outspoken Daisy and thoughtful Hazel works beautifully and shows different ways of being smart and capable.

Some kids might bounce off the boarding school formality or period language at first, but those who stick with it will find a genuinely engaging mystery that respects their intelligence. The series has a devoted following for good reason—it's well-written, clever, and features girls who solve their own problems. A solid choice for kids who've outgrown Magic Tree House but aren't quite ready for YA thrillers.

Age Fit

Best for ages 9-13 who are ready for mystery with a murder (no gore, very British cozy style) and can handle some historical prejudice shown in context. The reading level and boarding school setting might feel sophisticated to younger readers, while older middle schoolers will appreciate the detective work and friendship dynamics.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

82

Strong friendship between two girls drives the story, with Hazel (a Chinese student) dealing with 1930s prejudice while maintaining her dignity. The boarding school setting models cooperation and problem-solving. The tone is age-appropriate mystery fun without meanness or cruelty between the protagonists. Some period-typical snobbery exists but is contextualized through Hazel's perspective.

Imaginative

88

Two girls create their own detective agency in a classic Sherlock-Watson dynamic, complete with evidence-gathering, suspect-tracking, and deductive reasoning. The 1930s boarding school setting adds atmospheric intrigue. The central mystery—a body that disappears—invites readers to solve alongside the characters. The premise encourages kids to think like detectives and question what they observe.

Safe

78

Murder mystery for middle grade means a dead teacher, but handled appropriately for the age group—no graphic violence or gore. The body disappears quickly, keeping things mysterious rather than traumatic. Period prejudice against Hazel is present but shown as wrong and something she navigates with strength. No sexual content, profanity, or other inappropriate elements. The murder itself is the main concern, but it's cozy British mystery style, not graphic thriller.

Enriching

86

Teaches logical thinking, observation skills, and deductive reasoning through the detective work. Features a smart, capable Chinese protagonist in 1930s England, showing how to handle prejudice with grace and intelligence. The friendship dynamics explore loyalty and partnership. Historical setting provides context about boarding schools and social attitudes of the era. Encourages critical thinking about evidence and drawing conclusions. Strong 4.4 Amazon rating suggests readers find it engaging and worthwhile.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Smart, capable girl detectives who use logic and observation instead of waiting for adults to solve things
Hazel is a Chinese protagonist in 1930s England who handles prejudice with intelligence and dignity—great representation and historical context
Classic mystery structure that invites readers to solve alongside the characters, teaching deductive reasoning
Strong friendship between Daisy (outspoken leader) and Hazel (thoughtful observer) that shows different personality types working together
First in a beloved series, so if your kid loves it, there's plenty more to read

⚠

What to Watch For

It's a murder mystery, so there's a dead teacher—handled age-appropriately but still involves death and investigating suspects
Period-typical prejudice and snobbery toward Hazel as a Chinese student, though she handles it well and it's shown as wrong
Some kids might find the boarding school setting and 1930s language a bit formal or old-fashioned at first

Conversation Starters

"If you were starting a detective agency with your best friend, who would be the Sherlock and who would be the Watson? Why?"
"Hazel deals with people being prejudiced because she's Chinese. How does she handle it, and what would you do in her situation?"
"What clues would you look for if you were investigating the mystery? What makes someone a good detective?"
"The girls have to decide who to trust and who might be lying. How do you figure out when someone's telling the truth?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Morena Baccarin: A Parent’s Guide

A real-world guide to the sci-fi queen's work, from her hard-R hits to her 2026 turn as the Sorceress of Castle Grayskull.

Writing about Murder Is Bad Manners: Murder Most Unladylike, Book 1 Robin Stevens? Put this WISE score on your site