Is Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story suitable for teenagers?

No. The series carries an explicit adult rating due to brutal hatchet violence, graphic crime scene portrayals, and severe domestic distress. It is designed for adult audiences.

How violent is the show expected to be?

Expect realistic, visceral depictions of violent murders and graphic crime scene imagery, consistent with previous seasons of Ryan Murphy's Monster anthology.

Will trailers for this show pop up on my kid's profile?

Not if their profile is set to a restricted age tier. However, if they use an un-locked adult profile, heavy homepage promotion and auto-playing trailers will be visible.

Does the series follow real historical facts?

It anchors itself in the real 1892 murders and trial records, but heavily dramatizes character motives, private conversations, and psychological backstories for entertainment value.

Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show2026Drama, Crime

24%

WISE Score

8.0

TMDB

Ryan Murphy turns his true-crime lens on Fall River's 1892 double hatchet murders in a brutal Victorian drama strictly built for adults.

8.0

→

Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story

show

2026, Drama, Crime

24%

WISE Score

8.0

TMDB

Ryan Murphy turns his true-crime lens on Fall River's 1892 double hatchet murders in a brutal Victorian drama strictly built for adults.

8.0

Jump to

Also rated on

8.0

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Ryan Murphy's Monster franchise continues its run of dark, high-profile true-crime dramatizations by tackling the 1892 Fall River hatchet murders. The show pairs lavish Victorian production design with an unsettling look at the suffocating home life of Andrew and Abby Borden before their violent deaths.

Like previous entries in the series, it will not spare viewers the brutal details. Expect heavy atmosphere, graphic crime scene depictions, and intense psychological hostility. Keep this one behind account PINs so younger eyes do not stumble across auto-playing trailers or episodes.

Age Fit

This series is strictly for adults and mature older teens (17+). Between explicit hatchet violence, dark domestic themes, and graphic crime imagery, it belongs nowhere near a child's watchlist.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Depicts severe domestic abuse, toxic family dynamics, and brutal ax murders within a suffocating 1890s household.

Imaginative

Offers strong period set design and atmospheric staging, but stays locked inside a well-worn historical crime narrative.

Safe

Features explicit hatchet violence, graphic crime scene imagery, heavy psychological trauma, and intense domestic distress.

Enriching

Provides historical context regarding 19th-century gender norms and criminal justice, though sensationalized for dramatic effect.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

High-end period recreation brings 1890s Fall River, Massachusetts, and its tense social hierarchies to life.
Deep psychological focus explores the rigid, stifling household dynamics that led up to the famous murders.
Compelling historical drama for adult fans of true-crime history and high-budget television.

⚠

What to Watch For

Visceral hatchet violence and bloody crime scenes are central to the series; expect explicit gore.
Relentless emotional dysfunction including severe parental control, greed, and psychological abuse.
Prominent home screen promos mean auto-playing preview trailers could surprise younger kids on shared family accounts.

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think the 1892 Borden murders captivated the American press and public so intensely?"
"Where is the line between historical education and sensationalizing real-life tragedy?"
"How did 19th-century assumptions about women influence the jury during Lizzie Borden's trial?"

Deep Dive

The Ryan Murphy True-Crime Machine

Following entries focused on Jeffrey Dahmer and the Menendez brothers, Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story brings the franchise's signature stylized intensity to late 19th-century New England. The series leans into atmospheric dread, framing the Borden home as a pressure cooker of control, resentment, and isolation.

Sensational Drama vs. Historical Record

Lizzie Borden's acquittal in 1893 marked one of the nation's earliest media-fueled courtroom circuses. While the series draws on trial transcripts and historical reporting, viewers should expect heavily dramatized private moments designed to build narrative momentum rather than serve as a documentary transcript.

Managing Streaming Promos on Family Screens

Flagship releases from major platforms receive heavy banner placement and dynamic video teasers on the app home screen. If children or pre-teens share your main television setup, locking adult profiles behind a four-digit PIN ensures they won't meet graphic preview clips when booting up the TV.