Do I need to have watched other Harlan Coben shows first?

Not at all. While Netflix has a whole collection of his adaptations, they are all standalone stories. You can jump into this one without any homework.

How scary is the 'dating app' angle?

It’s more 'unsettling' than scary. It uses the app as a plot device to spark the mystery, rather than a commentary on the dangers of online dating. It’s more about the shock of seeing a dead person's face than a jump-scare.

Is there a lot of gore or violence?

It stays within the bounds of a standard TV-MA or TV-14 crime drama. There is some violence and crime scene tension, but it's not a 'slasher' or particularly graphic show.

Is it worth the time given the low audience scores?

If you are a die-hard mystery fan, you might enjoy the puzzle. But if you're looking for the next 'must-watch' series, the consensus says you can probably skip this one and not miss much.

Missing You – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Missing You

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show2025

48%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

A detective finds her long-lost fiancé on a dating app and discovers that matching with a ghost is a lot more complicated than a bad first date.

6.1/10

50%

31%

→

Missing You

show

TV-MA, 2025

48%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

A detective finds her long-lost fiancé on a dating app and discovers that matching with a ghost is a lot more complicated than a bad first date.

6.1

50%

Jump to

Also rated on

6.1/10

50%

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

If you've spent any time in the 'Coben-verse' on Netflix (Fool Me Once, The Stranger), you know the drill. Missing You tries to capture that same lightning, but the low audience scores suggest it’s more of a flicker this time around.

It’s a standard-issue mystery that’s fine for a rainy afternoon, but it’s not the kind of show that stays with you. If your teen is into mysteries, it's a safe enough pick, but there are better-executed thrillers on the platform that actually reward the viewer's attention.

Age Fit

This is firmly for the 14+ crowd. It’s an adult thriller that deals with adult relationships and the darker side of detective work, but there's nothing here that's going to shock a teenager who has seen a few episodes of Law & Order.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

It's a crime thriller centered on a missing person and secrets. While it deals with themes of persistence and justice, the overall tone is dark and suspenseful rather than emotionally uplifting.

Imaginative

Standard mystery procedural territory. The 'dating app match with a ghost' hook is a clever starting point, but it follows the established Harlan Coben thriller formula fairly closely.

Safe

Targeted at adults and older teens. Expect mature themes involving disappearance, crime scene tension, and the inherent 'creep factor' of matching with a missing person on a dating app.

Enriching

Good for exercising some logic and deduction, but audience scores suggest it doesn't quite land the emotional or intellectual payoff found in top-tier mysteries.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Harlan Coben completionists will find the familiar twisty-turny structure they've come to expect from his Netflix adaptations.
The detective procedural angle adds a layer of professional stakes beyond just a personal mystery.
It's a quick binge for mystery fans who just want a puzzle to solve over a weekend.

⚠

What to Watch For

The pacing can feel sluggish in the middle, which is likely why audience scores are sitting in the low 30s.
Expect some mildly intense crime scenes and the psychological weight of a cold case being ripped back open.
The dating app premise might feel a bit gimmicky if you're looking for a grounded, realistic detective drama.

Conversation Starters

"If someone you loved disappeared without a trace, how long would you keep looking?"
"Why do you think Kat decided to match with the profile instead of just calling the police immediately?"
"Do you think some secrets are actually better left in the past, or is the truth always worth the cost?"

Deep Dive

The Harlan Coben Factory

Netflix has a very specific pipeline for Harlan Coben adaptations, and Missing You is the latest off the assembly line. The premise is classic Coben: a professional (Detective Kat Donovan) is confronted by a ghost from her past (her fiancé, Josh) via a modern technological twist (a dating app). It’s designed to be clicked on.

However, the 31% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes is a loud signal. While the critics were lukewarm (50%), the people actually sitting through all the episodes felt let down. Usually, these shows thrive on 'one more episode' momentum, but here the mystery feels stretched thin.

Detective vs. Civilian

Unlike some of the other adaptations where a suburban parent is playing detective, Kat Donovan actually is a cop. This should make the show smarter, but it often falls into the trap of having her make 'movie cop' decisions that feel more like plot conveniences than actual police work.

If you have a teen who is obsessed with true crime or mystery novels, they’ll likely spot the twists coming from a mile away. It’s not a 'bad' show, but in a world with so much high-quality prestige TV, this feels like a filler episode for your watchlist.