Wait, is this the movie about the controversial book?

No. You might be seeing search results for Kathleen Stock's book Material Girls, which is about gender identity. This is the 2006 teen comedy movie starring the Duff sisters. Totally different vibes.

Is there any inappropriate content for a 10-year-old?

Not really. There's some very mild language, very light romantic interest (kissing/flirting), and some mean-spirited behavior between socialites, but it's very 'Disney Channel' in its execution.

Will my kid find this funny or just weird?

Honestly? Probably weird. The humor relies heavily on 2006 stereotypes that don't always translate to today's humor. It's more of a 'laugh at the fashion' experience now.

Material Girls – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Material Girls

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie2006

38%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

A mid-2000s time capsule of the Duff sisters trying to survive poverty (read: taking the bus) that is more cringe than classic.

4/10

44%

→

Material Girls

movie

PG, 2006

38%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

A mid-2000s time capsule of the Duff sisters trying to survive poverty (read: taking the bus) that is more cringe than classic.

Jump to

Also rated on

4/10

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Look, I’m all for a mindless throwback, but Material Girls is a tough sell in 2026. It’s a relic of an era where being 'famous for being famous' was the pinnacle of achievement, and it hasn't aged with the grace of something like Legally Blonde or even The Princess Diaries.

If your kid is on a Hilary Duff kick after seeing her in something else, go for it—it’s safe and short. But if you're looking for a quality family movie night, this isn't it. The 4% critic score on Rotten Tomatoes is, for once, exactly right.

Age Fit

Technically fine for anyone 9 and up, but the 'tween' humor and dated references mean kids older than 13 will likely find it unbearable.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

It attempts a 'money isn't everything' moral arc, but it's draped in 2000s consumerism and shallow characterizations that make the lesson feel unearned.

Imaginative

A paint-by-numbers 'riches-to-rags' story that doesn't offer a single original thought or creative visual choice.

Safe

Very low stakes. Beyond some mild 'mean girl' behavior and light flirting, there is nothing here to worry about.

Enriching

You get a tiny bit of 'hard work is good' messaging, but it's mostly a vacuum of substance.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Duff Sisters Nostalgia for parents or kids who want to see Hilary and Haylie at the height of their Disney-adjacent fame.
Harmless Fluff that doesn't require a single brain cell to process, making it a low-stress background movie.
Fashion Time Capsule that serves as a fascinating (and terrifying) look at 2006 trends like chunky belts and frosted lip gloss.

⚠

What to Watch For

The depiction of poverty is pretty tone-deaf; the movie treats using a public bus or working a regular job as a hilarious tragedy.
The acting and writing are objectively poor; even for a 'so-bad-it's-good' night, this one might just be 'so-bad-it's-boring.'

Conversation Starters

"If we lost everything tomorrow, what are the three things you'd miss the most that aren't people?"
"Do you think the sisters actually learned a lesson, or did they just get lucky?"
"How is being a 'famous heiress' in 2006 different from being a 'lifestyle influencer' today?"

Deep Dive

The 'Simple Life' Era on Film

To understand Material Girls, you have to remember the mid-2000s cultural obsession with Paris Hilton and Nicole Richie. This movie was a direct attempt to capitalize on that 'clueless socialite' trope. The plot—two sisters losing their cosmetics empire and having to solve a mystery to get it back—is really just a vehicle for the Duff sisters to wear outfits and look flustered by 'normal' life.

Why it struggles today

Modern kids are much more savvy about wealth and influencer culture. The 'struggles' the Marchetta sisters face—like having to clean their own house—don't land as funny satire anymore; they just feel dated. Unlike other films of the era that had a sharp wit, the script here is flaccid. Even the 'mystery' element is solved with very little agency from the leads.

The Duff Factor

Hilary Duff is genuinely charming in almost everything else she's done (Lizzie McGuire, Younger), but even her charisma can't save this. If you want a Duff sisters fix, you're better off finding old Lizzie reruns. Use this only if you want to show your kids what 'cringe' looked like twenty years ago.