Man with a Plan – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Man with a Plan

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show2016

48%

WISE Score

IMDb

Dad discovers parenting is hard when mom goes back to work—groundbreaking stuff from 2016 that feels like it's from 1996.

7/10

→

Man with a Plan

show

TV-PG, 2016

48%

WISE Score

IMDb

Dad discovers parenting is hard when mom goes back to work—groundbreaking stuff from 2016 that feels like it's from 1996.

Jump to

Also rated on

7/10

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Look, Man with a Plan isn't offensive or harmful, it's just...there. Like a beige couch from a furniture rental store. The premise—'dad learns parenting is hard'—was stale even in 2016, and nearly a decade later it feels like a relic.

The Metacritic score of 36 is brutal but fair. This is the kind of show networks greenlit because Matt LeBlanc was available and they needed something to fill a time slot. It's safe, it's predictable, and it will never surprise you—which might be exactly what some families want, but let's be honest: there are dozens of better family comedies available right now.

If you're looking for actual quality family sitcoms, try The Middle, Fresh Off the Boat, or even modern stuff like Abbott Elementary. This one's a pass unless you've literally exhausted every other option.

Age Fit

Best for ages 13+ per Common Sense Media, though honestly, teens will likely find it boring and outdated. This is really for parents who want undemanding background TV while folding laundry—not appointment viewing for anyone.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Traditional family sitcom that models parenting partnership and family cooperation, though relies heavily on tired gender stereotypes (dad can't handle 'mom's job'). The premise of a father learning parenting isn't inherently problematic, but the execution leans on outdated 'bumbling dad' tropes. Still, it avoids mean-spirited humor and centers on family problem-solving.

Imaginative

Standard multi-camera sitcom format with predictable storylines and conventional family scenarios. No creative risks, no unique perspective on family life, no invitation to think differently. It's paint-by-numbers network television that recycles familiar sitcom plots from the past 40 years.

Safe

CSM rates it 13+, which suggests mild language and some mature themes, but nothing shocking or inappropriate. Traditional sitcom format means no graphic content, violence, or sexual situations. The main safety concern is just mild innuendo and occasional adult humor typical of network TV family comedies.

Enriching

Limited educational or developmental value beyond basic 'families work together' messaging. The low Metacritic score (36) suggests critics found it uninspired. Might spark conversations about gender roles and parenting responsibilities, but doesn't offer much depth or meaningful insight. Entertainment value is middling—IMDb 7.0 suggests audience tolerance rather than enthusiasm.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Safe, predictable family sitcom if you need background noise that won't surprise you
Models the idea that both parents should be involved in childcare (even if clumsily)
Matt LeBlanc has charm, and some episodes land their jokes adequately
Available on multiple streaming platforms if you're already paying for Paramount+

⚠

What to Watch For

The entire premise rests on 'dad doesn't know how to parent'—which might irritate rather than amuse in 2025
Laugh track and multi-camera format feels dated; modern kids used to single-camera comedies may find it jarring
Metacritic score of 36 tells you what critics thought: this is aggressively mediocre
Mild language and adult humor appropriate for teens but not younger kids

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think TV shows used to make jokes about dads not knowing how to take care of their own kids?"
"What would make this show feel more modern or realistic?"
"Do you think both parents should know how to do everything for the family, or is it okay to have different roles?"

Stills

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Man with a Plan? Put this WISE score on your site