WISE Score
A high-octane Hawaii romp that swaps Tom Selleck's mustache for more explosions and a modern veteran bromance.
Magnum P.I. is the definition of 'background TV.' It’s bright, loud, and doesn't ask much of its audience. While it lacks the iconic charm of the 80s original, it leans hard into the modern action procedural formula with decent chemistry among the leads.
It’s not going to win any awards for deep storytelling, but for a family looking for a low-stakes action show that isn't as grim as modern crime dramas, it fits the bill. Just be prepared for a lot of Ferraris getting wrecked.
Best for kids 12 and up who are ready for standard network action violence but aren't looking for anything too dark or heavy.
The core of the show is the unshakable loyalty between former Navy SEALs. It models a healthy, supportive brotherhood and veteran community without being overly sentimental.
It's a standard network procedural that follows the reboot playbook closely. While the Hawaii setting is gorgeous, the storytelling relies on well-worn action tropes.
Typical TV-14 action. There are gunfights, explosions, and fistfights in every episode, but it avoids the graphic gore or sexual violence found in grittier cable dramas.
The show touches on the realities of post-service life and PTSD, offering some meaningful context for kids about the veteran experience amidst the car chases.
This reboot is essentially Hawaii Five-0 with a slightly different shirt. It ran until 2024, carving out a niche as a reliable, if uninspired, procedural. The biggest shift from the original is the character of Higgins, now Juliet Higgins, an ex-MI6 agent who provides a much-needed foil to Magnum’s rules-are-suggestions attitude.
For parents, the appeal here is the lack of 'prestige TV' baggage. There’s no sprawling, depressing mythology to track. It’s mostly monster-of-the-week storytelling set against a backdrop of blue water and expensive cars. It’s a decent bridge for middle-schoolers who are aging out of cartoons but aren't ready for the R-rated grit of streaming-service action movies. It treats its veteran characters with respect, which is a nice touch, even if their military skills usually just translate to being really good at punching people.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
