Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
It Starts with Us is the closure fans were screaming for after the trauma of the first book. While It Ends With Us was the 'hard watch' (or hard read), this is the therapy session.
Colleen Hoover isn't writing high literature here, but she is writing something that resonates deeply with people navigating real-world relationship baggage. It’s emotional, it’s a bit spicy, and it’s ultimately very hopeful. If your teen is already into romance novels, this is one of the 'healthier' ones in terms of the relationship dynamics it promotes, even if the 'spice' level is high.
Age Fit
This is strictly for the 15+ crowd. While younger teens might be tempted by the BookTok hype, the sexual content and the heavy themes of domestic abuse recovery are better suited for older teens who can process the nuance.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72
While it deals with the heavy fallout of domestic abuse, the core of this story is about healing, setting boundaries, and finding a healthy, respectful love. It's emotionally mature and models the 'green flags' we want kids to look for in partners eventually.
Imaginative
40
It's standard contemporary romance. It doesn't break new ground in terms of structure or world-building, but it does a decent job of putting you in the characters' heads.
Safe
55
Safe for older teens, but definitely not for the middle school crowd. It contains explicit sexual descriptions and honest depictions of the lingering fear following domestic violence. It's not 'dangerous,' but it's very much adult/mature YA fiction.
Enriching
82
Excellent for developing emotional intelligence. It tackles the nuance of co-parenting with a toxic ex and the courage it takes to start over. It's a masterclass in 'why healthy relationships matter.'
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Models what a healthy, respectful partner (Atlas) actually looks like compared to the 'toxic' tropes often found in romance.
Validates the messy, non-linear process of healing from trauma and divorce.
Extremely readable and fast-paced; it's the kind of book that turns non-readers into readers.
Focuses on the importance of a strong support system of friends and family.
⚠
What to Watch For
Explicit sexual content that is descriptive and geared toward an adult audience.
Ongoing tension and verbal manipulation from the protagonist's abusive ex-husband.
Strong language and mature themes regarding domestic violence and childhood neglect.
Conversation Starters
"How do you tell the difference between a grand romantic gesture and a red flag?"
"Why is it so hard for Lily to set boundaries with Ryle even after they are divorced?"
"What specific things does Atlas do to make Lily feel safe that Ryle never did?"
"How does the way Atlas treats his own family affect your opinion of him?"