Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is exactly what a solid preschool picture book should be: bright, funny, short, and just clever enough to keep parents from losing their minds during the 47th re-read.

The squid's swagger is genuinely entertaining—he's not mean-spirited, just confidently oblivious, which toddlers find hilarious. The twist (there's always a bigger fish, or in this case, whale) lands gently. Kevin Sherry's collage art does the heavy lifting here: those bold shapes and saturated colors are catnip for little eyes.

It's not going to change your kid's life or teach them the periodic table, but it'll hold their attention, introduce some ocean vocab, and maybe plant a tiny seed about perspective. Plus, it's blessedly short—you can knock this out in under two minutes, which is a gift when you're trying to get to bedtime.

Starred reviews from Kirkus and Publishers Weekly aren't handed out like candy, so this one clearly nails the preschool picture book formula. If you've got a toddler who loves sea creatures or just enjoys a character with unearned confidence, grab this one.

Age Fit

This is prime toddler and preschool territory (ages 2-5). The simple text, bold visuals, and repetitive structure hit the sweet spot for this age group. Babies will track the bright colors; toddlers will giggle at the squid's attitude. By kindergarten, most kids will have outgrown it.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

88

A delightfully boastful squid learns a gentle lesson in humility without any heavy-handedness. The tone is playful and self-aware—the squid's hubris is endearing rather than obnoxious, and the comeuppance (discovering something bigger) lands with humor instead of shame. The simple narrative models confidence while gently poking fun at excessive pride. Perfect emotional pacing for toddlers and preschoolers.

Imaginative

75

Bold, bright collage art with simple shapes creates a visually striking underwater world. The concept of comparing sizes invites kids to think about relative scale and marine life. However, the narrative itself is fairly straightforward—it's a linear comparison exercise with a punchline. The creativity lies more in the execution and visual design than in the story structure. Still, it sparks curiosity about ocean creatures and their sizes.

Safe

98

Zero concerns. This is a picture book about a squid comparing itself to clams, shrimp, and fish. No scary content, no mature themes, no surprises. The 'conflict' is discovering a whale is bigger—gentle and age-appropriate. The 4.8 Amazon rating and starred reviews from Kirkus and Publishers Weekly confirm broad parent approval. Books don't get safer than this.

Enriching

72

Introduces ocean animals and the concept of size comparison in an accessible way for very young readers. The gentle lesson about perspective (you're not always the biggest) lands without being preachy. The repetitive structure supports early literacy and prediction skills. However, it's primarily entertaining rather than deeply educational—there's not much depth beyond 'here are sea creatures and their relative sizes.' Still, that's exactly what a good preschool book should do.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Bold, eye-catching collage art that babies and toddlers lock onto immediately—simple shapes, bright colors, high contrast
The repetitive structure ('I'm bigger than a clam! I'm bigger than a fish!') is perfect for early readers who love prediction and participation
Gentle lesson in humility that lands with humor instead of a lecture—the squid's confidence isn't punished, just put in perspective
Short enough to hold toddler attention but engaging enough for multiple re-reads without parent brain rot
Introduces ocean creatures in a fun, accessible way that might spark curiosity about marine life

⚠

What to Watch For

This is squarely aimed at the 2-5 crowd—older kids will find it too simple and move on quickly
The lesson is gentle to the point of being almost nonexistent; if you're looking for deep moral teaching, this ain't it
Some kids might fixate on the 'biggest' concept and start their own comparison competitions (which, honestly, is developmentally normal)

Conversation Starters

"What's the biggest thing YOU've ever seen? Was it bigger than you?"
"Do you think the squid was sad when he saw the whale, or just surprised?"
"What other animals live in the ocean? Are they bigger or smaller than you?"
"Have you ever felt really big and then saw something even bigger? How did that feel?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Dive Into Ocean Books Inspired by Finding Nemo, Moana, and The Little Mermaid

Turn your child's love of Disney ocean adventures into a reading journey that builds literacy and wonder.

I'm the Biggest Thing in the Ocean: A Guide to Big Egos and Bigger Perspectives

Help your preschooler navigate comparisons and confidence with this quirky tale of a boastful squid who learns there's always a bigger fish.

Writing about I'm the Biggest Thing in the Ocean? Put this WISE score on your site