Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Look, if you're an adult who loves Emily Henry's brand of emotionally wrought beach reads, you probably already know if this is your thing. It's competently written romantic angst with a Maine cottage backdrop and the kind of 'will they won't they' tension that keeps pages turning.
But let's be real: this isn't enriching literature or even particularly imaginative—it's the literary equivalent of comfort food that might leave you feeling a bit heavy afterward. The constant sexual tension, explicit scenes, and premise built on deception make it firmly adult territory. And the emotional landscape is pretty draining: anger, sadness, frustration, rinse, repeat.
For parents? This has zero relevance to your kids' media diet. It's adult romance with adult content. The 4.2 Amazon rating suggests it's fine for what it is, but 'what it is' is standard contemporary romance that won't challenge you much beyond making you feel feelings about relationships. If you need a plane read and like this genre, sure. But don't expect more than that.
Age Fit
This is squarely adult contemporary romance (18+) with explicit sexual content and emotionally mature themes around relationship dissolution, career identity, and adult friendships. Not appropriate for teens despite the 'beach read' branding.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
45
While the core themes of friendship and navigating heartbreak have merit, the emotional landscape is heavy with sadness, anger, and frustration. The constant focus on romantic/sexual tension and the central premise of lying to friends for a week doesn't model healthy communication or emotional processing. The relationship dynamics lean more melancholic than uplifting.
Imaginative
38
Standard contemporary romance structure with a fake-dating-adjacent premise that's been done extensively. The Maine cottage setting provides some atmospheric detail, but the narrative is primarily focused on internal emotional processing and relationship rehashing rather than creative world-building or original storytelling. Doesn't invite reader creativity or exploration beyond passive consumption.
Safe
35
Per Common Sense Media, sexual content is near-constant with frequent kissing, embracing, occasional nudity, and explicit sex scenes (including condom purchase and descriptions of the act). While no violence, the sexual content makes this inappropriate for younger readers who might pick up a beach read. The emotional intensity around breakups and relationship dysfunction could also be triggering for some readers.
Enriching
48
Explores adult themes of identity, career pressure, relationship compromise, and the evolution of friendships over time. Some emotional insight into how people grow apart and the difficulty of honest communication. However, it's primarily entertainment-focused emotional wallowing rather than offering meaningful takeaways or personal growth frameworks. The 'lying to friends' premise undermines potential ethical enrichment.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Explores the messy reality of relationships ending and the difficulty of moving on when your lives are deeply intertwined
Strong sense of place with the Maine coastal cottage setting and friend-group dynamics
Henry's writing style is accessible and emotionally evocative for readers who enjoy slow-burn romantic tension
Touches on real adult pressures: career demands, geographic incompatibility, and how people change in their twenties
⚠
What to Watch For
Frequent sexual content including explicit scenes, nudity, and near-constant romantic/sexual thoughts throughout
Emotionally heavy—lots of sadness, anger, and relationship dysfunction that might feel draining
The central premise involves lying to close friends for an entire week, which isn't exactly modeling great communication
This is adult contemporary romance, not YA—despite being shelved as 'beach read,' it's firmly for grown-ups
Conversation Starters
"Have you ever kept a secret from friends to avoid hurting them? How did that work out?"
"What do you think makes a relationship worth fighting for versus knowing when to let go?"
"The characters struggle with career vs. relationship priorities—how would you navigate that kind of conflict?"
"Do you think it's possible to stay close friends with an ex? What would make that work or not work?"