Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is exactly what a holiday picture book should be: funny, warm, educational without being boring, and genuinely enjoyable to read multiple times. Eric Kimmel knows how to tell a story that works for both kids and the adults reading to them.
The premise is ridiculous in the best way—a bear eating latkes and spinning a dreidel while an elderly woman cheerfully hosts him—and it manages to teach about Hanukkah traditions without feeling like a textbook. The National Jewish Book Award and bestseller status aren't flukes; this is a well-crafted story that's become a modern holiday classic for good reason.
At 4.9/5 stars on Amazon and strong recommendations across the board, parents clearly love this one. It's accessible for non-Jewish families learning about the holiday and meaningful for Jewish families celebrating it. The included recipe and educational back matter add real value beyond the story itself.
The only caveat: it's seasonal. But for Hanukkah reading? This is top-tier.
Age Fit
Perfect for preschool through early elementary (ages 3-8), with the sweet spot around 4-6. The story is simple enough for young listeners but funny enough to keep slightly older kids engaged. Works beautifully as a read-aloud during Hanukkah season.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
A warm, gentle story about mistaken identity that models hospitality, kindness, and sharing. Bubba Brayna welcomes who she thinks is her rabbi into her home without hesitation, sharing her meal and traditions. The humor is sweet and age-appropriate—a bear accidentally celebrating Hanukkah—with no meanness or conflict. The tone is cozy and inviting, perfect for holiday reading.
Imaginative
78
The premise is delightfully absurd: a near-blind elderly woman mistakes a bear for her rabbi and the bear plays along, spinning dreidels and eating latkes. Wohnoutka's illustrations bring humor and whimsy to life. It's a creative reworking of a classic tale with just enough silliness to engage young readers, though the story itself is fairly straightforward without deep layers of imagination or world-building.
Safe
98
This is as safe as children's books get. No scary content, no violence, no mature themes. The bear is portrayed as adorable and hungry, not threatening. The story is predictable and comforting. Perfect for reading aloud without any concerns about unexpected content. The only 'conflict' is the humorous reveal at the end when everyone realizes who ate the latkes.
Enriching
85
A National Jewish Book Award winner that introduces Hanukkah traditions—lighting the menorah, playing dreidel, eating latkes—in an accessible, entertaining way. Includes back matter with latke recipes and digestible facts about Hanukkah history and customs. The story models generosity and hospitality while teaching cultural literacy. It's both educational and genuinely fun, making it an excellent introduction to Jewish holidays for kids of all backgrounds.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
National Jewish Book Award winner with a 4.9/5 Amazon rating and #1 bestseller status in children's Jewish books
Introduces Hanukkah traditions (menorah, dreidel, latkes) through genuinely funny storytelling rather than didactic explanation
The humor works on multiple levels—kids laugh at the absurdity while adults appreciate the gentle comedy of errors
Includes practical back matter with a latke recipe and Hanukkah facts that families can actually use
Models radical hospitality and kindness without being preachy about it
⚠
What to Watch For
Specifically a Hanukkah story, so it's seasonal reading that might not get pulled off the shelf year-round
The humor relies on Bubba Brayna's poor eyesight and hearing, which some kids might need help understanding isn't mean-spirited
Best for families looking to learn about or celebrate Jewish traditions—it's educational in the best way
Conversation Starters
"What would you do if a bear showed up at our door? Would you know it wasn't a person?"
"Why do you think Bubba Brayna was so welcoming to her guest, even before she knew who it was?"
"Have you ever mistaken one thing for another? What happened?"
"What's your favorite Hanukkah tradition from the story? Should we try making latkes together?"