Clean, 2023, Society & Culture, Comedy
WISE Score
Josh Peck and Ben Soffer riff on the absurdity of modern fatherhood and pop culture with the kind of loud, chaotic banter that makes a solo commute feel like a hang.
Good Guys is a solid, chaotic comedy pod that works best as a personal escape for parents rather than a family listen. If you're looking for Josh Peck to be the goofy kid from Drake & Josh, you'll find bits of it, but he’s mostly here to be a real, unfiltered adult.
It’s loud, it’s often funny, and it’s definitely explicit. Save it for the gym or the car when you're finally flying solo.
This is content for adults, specifically millennial parents. While teenagers who grew up with Josh Peck might enjoy the nostalgia, the 'guy talk' and explicit language aren't meant for younger audiences.
The hosts are generally well-meaning and heartfelt, especially when discussing fatherhood, though the 'perfectly chaotic' energy keeps it from being a calm listen.
Standard conversational format with banter and pop culture riffing; not a creative or narrative-driven experience.
Frequent explicit language and adult topics make this inappropriate for kids to overhear, though it's standard for adult comedy podcasts.
Provides light entertainment and relatability for parents, but lacks educational or skill-building depth.
If you grew up watching Drake & Josh, seeing Josh Peck as a fully-realized, slightly stressed-out dad is a trip. He’s teamed up with Ben Soffer (known to the internet as @boywithnojob) to create a show that feels less like a structured interview and more like a loud dinner party where everyone is talking over each other.
The Good Guys branding isn't a lie—they generally come across as decent people trying to figure out adult life—but don't mistake that for family-friendly. This is a show for the parents. They tackle everything from the weirdness of influencer culture to the specific exhaustion of parenting a toddler, all delivered with a frantic, high-energy pacing that keeps things moving.
It fits into that specific niche of millennial nostalgia turned reality. If you're looking for deep, investigative journalism, keep scrolling. But if you want to hear two guys argue about whether a specific brand of sparkling water is trash while also being surprisingly vulnerable about their anxieties, this is your move. It’s chaotic, it’s loud, and it’s a solid reminder that even the people who grew up on your TV screen are just as confused about being adults as you are.
Get a personalized guide on any topic