Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the gold standard for theater-kid fiction. Tim Federle (who went on to run the High School Musical series) knows this world inside out and writes with a sharp, fast-paced wit that keeps modern kids engaged.
It’s a rare sequel that’s actually better than the original. It doesn't treat kids like they're stupid, and it doesn't shy away from the fact that growing up and figuring out who you are is a total circus. If your kid feels like a bit of an outsider, Nate is the friend they need on their bookshelf.
Age Fit
Perfect for the 9-13 crowd, especially the ones who have the 'Hamilton' or 'Wicked' soundtracks on a permanent loop. It’s middle-school humor with a Broadway budget.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
It’s got a massive heart. Nate is a kid who actually cares about his friends and family, even when he’s dealing with the high-stakes ego-trip that is a Broadway rehearsal room.
Imaginative
82
The book is a love letter to the creative process. It doesn't just talk about 'dreams'; it shows the messy, creative work of building a character and a show from scratch.
Safe
95
It’s a middle-grade book through and through. It deals with identity and first crushes in a way that’s totally appropriate and honest for the age group without any shock-value content.
Enriching
90
It’s a masterclass in empathy for kids who feel like 'misfits.' Plus, the career-path insight into the professional theater world is actually quite educational for any kid with a hobby they take seriously.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
The theater 'insider' vibes are 100% authentic—Tim Federle lived this life, and it shows.
Nate’s internal monologue is genuinely funny and relatable, not that 'cringe' adult-trying-to-be-a-teenager voice.
It tackles the reality of being a 'second choice' (understudy) and how to keep your chin up when you aren't the star.
Great for boys who feel like they don't fit the 'sports and video games' mold.
⚠
What to Watch For
Some 'showbiz' snark and mild middle-school social drama.
Nate deals with some family friction and the pressure of living in NYC away from home.
Conversation Starters
"If you were an understudy and the lead got sick, would you feel guilty or just stoked to finally go on?"
"Nate’s pretty obsessed with Broadway—what’s the one thing you’re that 'geeky' about?"
"How do you handle it when your best friend is competing for the same thing you want?"