Is there a lot of nudity or sex in this show?

While it's not HBO-level, it's an Amazon Prime romance, so expect some fairly intense making-out and implied sexual content. It's definitely aimed at a more 'mature' teen or adult audience rather than the middle-school crowd.

Is the 'one moment to fall apart' too intense for sensitive viewers?

Without spoiling it, the conflict is more emotional than physical. It deals with betrayal and regret, which might be heavy for kids currently dealing with their own social drama, but it's not 'trigger warning' territory for most.

Do I need to have read the book first?

Not at all. The show stands on its own, though like most adaptations, fans of the original story will probably have strong opinions about the casting and the changes to the timeline.

Why is the audience score so much lower than the critic score?

Audience frustration usually boils down to pacing. Some viewers find the 'will-they-won't-they' across six summers to be more exhausting than romantic. If you don't like slow-burn dramas, this might feel like a slog.

Every Year After – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Every Year After

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show2026

58%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

Six summers of nostalgia and one messy breakup. It's basically a beach read that decided to move into your living room for eight episodes.

6.4/10

70%

53%

→

Every Year After

show

M18, 2026

58%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

Six summers of nostalgia and one messy breakup. It's basically a beach read that decided to move into your living room for eight episodes.

6.4

70%

Jump to

Also rated on

6.4/10

70%

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Every Year After is the TV equivalent of a paperback you buy at the airport—it's familiar, a bit manipulative, and exactly what you expect. It's not reinventing the wheel, and the low audience scores suggest it might be a bit of a slog for anyone who isn't already a die-hard romance fan.

If your teen is into The Summer I Turned Pretty, they'll probably eat this up. Just be ready for the 'toxic but destined' tropes that usually come packaged with this kind of sweeping drama. It's safe enough for a high-schooler, but maybe keep the remote handy if you're watching with younger kids and want to skip the more intense romantic beats.

Age Fit

Best for 14 and up. It’s a mature look at first love that might bore younger kids, but it hits that specific 'second-chance romance' sweet spot for older teens and adults.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

It centers on long-term connection and emotional growth, but the heavy focus on breakups and 'falling apart' means it spends as much time in the mess as it does in the resolution.

Imaginative

The non-linear, six-summer structure is a nice touch, but it’s a standard romantic drama that doesn't push many creative boundaries outside the genre tropes.

Safe

Likely falls into the TV-14/TV-MA romance bucket. No reports of extreme violence or toxicity, but expect the usual 'steamy' Amazon Prime romance levels.

Enriching

Offers some decent jumping-off points for talking about forgiveness and how people change over a decade, though it leans more on melodrama than deep insight.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Emotional intelligence is at the forefront as the characters navigate a decade of mistakes and personal growth.
Nostalgia vibes are heavy, capturing that specific feeling of teenage summers that feel like they'll last forever.
Non-linear storytelling keeps the 'what went wrong' mystery alive across the six-summer timeline, making it more than just a chronological slog.
Scenic production makes for a great 'vibe watch' if you just want to look at beautiful summer houses and lakes.

⚠

What to Watch For

The audience score is notably lower than the critic score, usually a sign that the pacing is slow or the ending is divisive.
Expect some mature romantic content—Amazon's recent track record with YA-adjacent romance tends to lean into the 'steamy' side of things.
The 'soulmate' trope is laid on thick, which can sometimes romanticize obsessive behavior or the idea that you can't move on from a first love.

Conversation Starters

"Do you think people really have one 'soulmate,' or is that just a movie thing?"
"How do you think the characters handled their big mistake differently as they got older?"
"Why is it so much harder to forgive someone you've known your whole life compared to a new friend?"
"What are the signs that a relationship is 'meant to be' versus just being stuck in the past?"

Deep Dive

The Nostalgia Trap

Amazon Prime Video has been leaning hard into the 'Summer Romance' genre lately, and Every Year After is their latest attempt to capture that Daisy Jones or Summer I Turned Pretty magic. The hook—six summers of history vs. one week to fix it—is classic romance structure. It works because it exploits our collective weakness for 'what if' scenarios and the idealized version of our younger selves.

Critics vs. The Couch

The 70% critic score vs. 53% audience score is the most interesting thing about this show. Usually, that gap means the show is technically well-made—good acting, beautiful cinematography—but it fails to actually satisfy the people watching it. In the romance genre, this often happens when the 'big reveal' of why the couple broke up doesn't feel earned, or when the characters spend too much time moping and not enough time talking.

The 'Soulmate' Problem

From a developmental standpoint, it’s worth watching this with a slightly critical eye. The show pushes the narrative that your first love is your only love. That’s a fun fantasy, but in the real world, it can be a bit of a heavy burden for teens to carry. If you're watching this with a 15-year-old, it's a great time to talk about the difference between a high-stakes TV drama and a healthy, functional relationship that doesn't require a decade of 'falling apart' to work.