Do we need to read the previous Dog Man books in order before Big Jim Believes?

For the first five or six books, order didn't matter much, but the newer entries have surprisingly deep ongoing storylines. Big Jim Believes picks up directly on threads from The Scarlet Shedder (like Dog Man's skunk-stained alter-ego, the Space Cuties From Space, and Grampa's redemption issues). A kid can still enjoy the slapstick cold, but they'll get way more out of it if they've read the recent ones.

Will the intentional misspellings mess up my kid's actual spelling?

Almost certainly not. The books are framed as comics created by two fourth-graders (George and Harold), so signs and sound effects are sometimes spelled phonetically. In practice, kids love spotting the mistakes because it makes them feel smarter than the book, and Dav Pilkey has actually toned down the misspellings in the newer volumes compared to Book 1.

My kid reads this in 30 minutes and then re-reads it 10 times. Should I push them toward 'real' chapter books?

Re-reading a favorite graphic novel ten times is fantastic for building reading fluency and sight-word recognition. You don't need to take Dog Man away to build higher-level comprehension — just layer in a richer chapter book as a parent read-aloud or put on an audiobook in the car so both halves of their literacy are growing.

How much potty humor is in this one compared to Captain Underpants?

Dog Man is noticeably tamer and sweeter than Captain Underpants. You still get butt jokes, dog behaviors (drinking from toilets, rolling in dead fish), and silly superhero names, but the tone in the recent books leans much harder into emotional warmth, therapy-adjacent lessons about self-awareness, and family dynamics.

Dog Man: Big Jim Believes – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Dog Man: Big Jim Believes

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2025Juvenile Fiction

90%

WISE Score

Big Jim's relentless optimism takes center stage against the Space Cuties From Space in another loud, heartfelt installment of Dav Pilkey's juggernaut.

Dog Man: Big Jim Believes

book

2025, Juvenile Fiction

90%

WISE Score

Big Jim's relentless optimism takes center stage against the Space Cuties From Space in another loud, heartfelt installment of Dav Pilkey's juggernaut.

Jump to

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.

Screenwise Verdict

By fourteen books into a graphic novel series about a cop with a dog's head, you would expect the whole thing to be running on fumes. Instead, Dav Pilkey has turned Dog Man into a weirdly sincere, emotionally earnest soap opera for seven-year-olds. Big Jim Believes brings back the Space Cuties From Space and puts the spotlight on Big Jim (Commander Cupcake), Sprinkles, and Mecha Molly while continuing the long-running tug-of-war over trust, redemption, and Grampa's cynicism.

If you've ever worried that graphic novels are "junk food" reading, let that go. Kids tearing through a 200-page Dog Man book in an afternoon are doing real decoding practice — mapping letters to sounds, tracking narrative structure, and using visual context clues to figure out words above their grade level. It's loud, silly, and still features Flip-O-Rama pages that threaten the structural integrity of the binding, but the message underneath about integrity and believing in people is genuinely good.

Age Fit

Sweet spot is ages 6 to 10 for independent reading, or 5+ as a chaotic bedtime read-aloud if you are willing to do the voices. Most kids age out around 11 unless they're reading it for nostalgia.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Beneath the relentless potty jokes and intentional misspellings, Dav Pilkey's later Dog Man books lean heavily into sincerity. This installment centers on Big Jim's earnest optimism, forgiveness, and characters learning to trust each other after past mistakes.

Imaginative

The meta-fictional comic-book-made-by-fourth-graders framing, interactive Flip-O-Rama pages, and absurd sci-fi villains like the Space Cuties From Space frequently inspire kids to fold up printer paper and draw their own comics.

Safe

Zero real-world danger or mature themes. The conflicts are cartoon slapstick involving giant robots, superhero alter-egos, and goofy villains, all completely safe for elementary readers.

Enriching

The decoding practice is massive for reluctant or developing readers who might balk at a wall of text, and the themes around self-awareness, redemption (especially with Grampa), and emotional resilience give it real heart.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Reluctant-reader rocket fuel that gets kids putting eyes on text and building decoding fluency without feeling like homework.
Surprisingly earnest emotional core focused on Big Jim's positivity, self-awareness, and how characters handle trust and Grampa's ongoing friction.
DIY creative spark — because the books are framed as comics drawn by two kids (George and Harold), readers frequently put the book down and start stapling their own blank paper together.
Visual scaffolding lets younger readers use panel art to decode tougher vocabulary and follow complex plot threads involving alter-egos like Scarlet Shedder and Commander Cupcake.

⚠

What to Watch For

Phonetic spelling in the dialogue is part of the series' joke (since two kids 'wrote' it), which occasionally annoys parents worried about spelling tests, though kids almost always recognize it as a gag.
Flip-O-Rama wear and tear — the interactive flip-animation pages are a blast, but enthusiastic six-year-olds will rip them right out of a library copy if they aren't careful.
Continuity-heavy plotting — unlike the earliest books in the series, the recent entries carry ongoing character arcs (Mecha Molly, Grampa, Scarlet Shedder), so jumping in cold here will be slightly confusing.

Conversation Starters

"Is Big Jim ever annoying with how positive he is, or does it actually help the team?"
"Why do you think Grampa has such a hard time trusting anyone or changing his ways?"
"If you were making a Flip-O-Rama page right now, what two drawings would you put in it?"
"Who has the better superhero name: Scarlet Shedder or Commander Cupcake?"

Deep Dive

The evolution from potty jokes to therapy-speak

Early Dog Man books were pure anarchic slapstick, closer in spirit to Pilkey's Captain Underpants. Over the last half-dozen installments, the series shifted noticeably. While the sight gags and superhero team-ups (Dog Man in his Scarlet Shedder era, Big Jim as Commander Cupcake, and psychokinetic tadpole Molly in her Mecha suit) are still front and center, the actual conflict is almost always internal.

In Big Jim Believes, the return of the Space Cuties From Space warps the city, forcing the characters to figure out how to trust each other when everything looks wrong. Big Jim's whole deal has always been aggressive, golden-retriever-level optimism in the face of cynicism (usually Petey's or Grampa's). Giving him the thematic lead makes for a sweet story about whether innocence and positive belief are a weakness or a superpower.

How to handle the "is this real reading?" question

Teachers and reading specialists love Dog Man for a practical reason: stamina. A second-grader who freezes up looking at a solid page of chapter-book text will happily read five hundred pages of Pilkey in a week.

Under the hood of literacy science, reading takes both word recognition (decoding the words on the page) and language comprehension (following plot, character motivation, and vocabulary). Graphic novels give developing decoders a massive assist by pairing the text with immediate visual feedback, keeping them engaged long enough to build speed and sight recognition. If your kid only reads Dog Man right now, let them cook — and if you want to stretch their language comprehension at the same time, put on a higher-level audiobook during car rides or read a meatier chapter book aloud at bedtime.

Where to go next

If they finish Big Jim Believes in forty-five minutes and immediately ask for another one:

Cat Kid Comic Club: Pilkey's spin-off series starring Li'l Petey and Molly. It mixes traditional drawing with photography, claymation, and pipe-cleaner art, and is even more focused on getting kids to make their own stories.
InvestiGators by John Patrick Green: The closest sibling to Dog Man in pacing and visual energy, swapping the potty humor for an unrelenting barrage of dad-joke puns.
Hilo by Judd Winick: A slightly more structured sci-fi graphic novel series with great comedic timing and longer overarching mysteries.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Big Jim and the Big Reveal: What to Know About Dog Man #15

'A Sprinkle in Time' finally explains the giant purple cat’s tragic backstory—and it’s a surprisingly heavy reveal about Grampa.

Morena Baccarin: A Parent’s Guide

A real-world guide to the sci-fi queen's work, from her hard-R hits to her 2026 turn as the Sorceress of Castle Grayskull.

Writing about Dog Man: Big Jim Believes? Put this WISE score on your site