Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Look, it’s Dog Man. It’s loud, it’s silly, and there are jokes about flatulence. But Dav Pilkey has this secret sauce where he sneaks in real heart and literary references while your kid thinks they’re just looking at a dog in a police hat.
This specific volume is widely considered one of the best in the series because of the introduction of Lil' Petey. He brings a level of sweetness that balances out the chaos and actually gives the 'villain' Petey a chance to grow. If you want your kid to actually enjoy opening a book instead of treating it like a chore, this is a must-have.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 6 to 10. It’s the sweet spot for kids who are graduating from picture books but still want high-energy visuals and humor.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
82
The story centers on the redemptive power of love and the choice to be good. The relationship between the 'villain' Petey and his sweet clone Lil' Petey is surprisingly tender, modeling kindness and patience amidst the slapstick chaos.
Imaginative
92
Dav Pilkey's 'book-within-a-book' format encourages kids to see themselves as creators. The inclusion of 'Flip-O-Rama' animation and drawing guides turns a passive reading experience into an active, creative one.
Safe
98
As a physical book, it's free of digital risks. Content-wise, it's very safe, featuring only cartoonish slapstick and mild potty humor that is standard for the 7+ demographic.
Enriching
88
A powerhouse for literacy, especially for reluctant readers. It uses wordplay, puns on classic literature (Dickens), and sophisticated themes of nature vs. nurture disguised as silly comics.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
The ultimate 'reluctant reader' bait—it's fast, funny, and visually engaging enough to compete with screens.
Lil' Petey is a genuinely sweet character who models radical kindness and optimism in the face of cynicism.
Interactive 'Flip-O-Rama' pages and drawing tutorials keep kids' hands moving and their brains engaged.
Surprisingly deep themes about choosing your own identity rather than just being what you were 'made' to be.
⚠
What to Watch For
Heavy reliance on potty humor (toilets, smells, and 'pee-pee' jokes) which might grate on some parents but delights the target age.
Intentional misspellings in the narration (designed to look like a kid's comic) that some educators find polarizing, though they don't actually hinder literacy.
Conversation Starters
"Why does Lil' Petey want to be good even though he's a clone of a 'bad' guy?"
"Petey tries to teach Lil' Petey to be evil, but it doesn't work. Do you think people are born 'good' or 'bad'?"
"If you could use 'Living Spray' on one object in your room, what would it be and what would you do with it?"
