College Football 25 – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

College Football 25

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

game2024

76%

WISE Score

88%

IGDB

The first college football game in over a decade brings clean, authentic gridiron action for fans of all ages.

College Football 25

game

2024

76%

WISE Score

88%

IGDB

The first college football game in over a decade brings clean, authentic gridiron action for fans of all ages.

Jump to

Also rated on

IGDB88

View →

Where to Play

Xbox

PlayStation

Screenwise Verdict

This is exactly what it says on the tin: a well-executed college football simulator that's squeaky clean and perfect for families who love the sport.

The 11-year gap since the last NCAA Football game makes this a big deal for fans, and EA Orlando delivered solid gameplay with authentic college atmospheres. Your football-obsessed kid can finally play as their favorite school, and you won't worry about what they're seeing on screen.

The main caveat is EA's Ultimate Team mode, which includes card packs (loot boxes by another name). If your kid gets hooked on building the perfect team, you might see requests for "just one more pack." Set boundaries early or stick to Dynasty mode, which is the heart of the game anyway.

For non-football families, this won't convert anyone - it's a sports sim through and through. But if your household already watches games on Saturdays, this is a no-brainer addition that everyone can enjoy without content concerns.

Age Fit

Best for ages 8+ who understand football basics and can handle the strategic depth. The E rating is accurate - there's nothing objectionable here - but younger kids may find the playbook complexity overwhelming. Appeals to teens and adults who follow college football, making it genuine family gaming material.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Clean sports simulation with no profanity, sexual content, or substance use. Models teamwork and sportsmanship inherent to football. Only mild violence from standard tackle animations. Plugged In confirms 'no genuinely objectionable content,' making it a solid choice for young football fans.

Imaginative

Sports simulators prioritize realism over creativity. Players can build custom dynasties and recruit teams across 134 FBS schools, offering strategic depth and roster management. However, the gameplay follows real-world football rules with limited room for imaginative play compared to open-world or creative games.

Safe

ESRB rated E for Everyone with users interact feature. ESRB listing notes 'In-Game Purchases (Includes Random Items)' which raises mild monetization concerns, though this appears to be Ultimate Team card packs common in EA sports titles. Online interactions are present but the game lacks open chat. Gameplay is predictable tackle football with no surprise mature content.

Enriching

Teaches football strategy, playbook execution, and team management. Dynasty mode offers long-term planning and resource allocation skills. Players learn about college football programs, rivalries, and traditions. However, entertainment value centers on sports fandom rather than broader cognitive or ethical development. IGDB rating of 87.6 suggests strong execution.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Completely clean content - no profanity, sexual content, or substance use, just football
134 FBS schools with authentic atmospheres, fight songs, and traditions that football-loving families can enjoy together
Dynasty mode teaches strategic thinking, roster management, and long-term planning
First college football game since 2013, filling a huge gap for fans who've been waiting
Strong gameplay execution (IGDB 87.6) means it's actually fun to play, not just nostalgia bait

⚠

What to Watch For

Ultimate Team mode includes card packs (random item purchases) - classic EA monetization that can add up fast
Online multiplayer means your kid will face other players who may have spent money on better teams
It's still football - repetitive tackle animations and standard sports game structure won't appeal to non-fans
Requires current-gen consoles (PS5/Xbox Series X|S) - not accessible on older hardware

Conversation Starters

"Which college team are you rooting for in Dynasty mode? What made you pick them?"
"What's your recruiting strategy - do you go for star players or build team chemistry?"
"How does college football differ from the NFL? Why do you think the rules are different?"
"If you could design your own college football program, what would your team colors and mascot be?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic