Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
James Ponti is essentially the gold standard for modern middle-grade thrillers. City Spies succeeds because it doesn't talk down to kids; it assumes they are smart, capable, and interested in how the world actually works.
If your kid has already burned through Spy School or Alex Rider, this is the logical next step. It’s more emotionally resonant than the former and less grim than the latter. It’s a high-quality, high-velocity read that actually teaches a bit of geography and ethics along the way.
Age Fit
The sweet spot is ages 8–12. It’s sophisticated enough for middle-schoolers who want a break from 'baby' books, but clean enough for advanced 3rd graders who are ready for a longer series.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Strong focus on found family, teamwork among kids from diverse backgrounds, and using unique skills for a greater good. The mentorship from the adult lead, 'Mother,' is supportive rather than exploitative.
Imaginative
92
The 'City Spies' concept is a clever twist on the genre, giving each kid a specific, grounded specialty (hacking, sleight of hand, etc.) and placing them in real-world global locations like Paris and Scotland.
Safe
90
Standard middle-grade action. There is peril (dangling from buildings, stopping villains), but it's largely bloodless and focused on cleverness over violence. No major content red flags for the target age.
Enriching
94
Excellent for building global awareness and vocabulary. It integrates geography, history, and logic puzzles into the plot, encouraging readers to think through problems alongside the characters.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Diverse representation that feels earned, not forced, with five kids from different continents bringing unique cultural perspectives.
Grounded spycraft that favors hacking, social engineering, and logic over magical gadgets or impossible physics.
Fast-paced plotting that keeps even reluctant readers engaged without sacrificing character depth or smart dialogue.
Found-family vibes that provide a warm emotional center, especially for kids who feel like outsiders.
⚠
What to Watch For
The protagonist, Sara, starts the book in juvenile detention after hacking the foster care system, which might spark questions about 'good' vs 'bad' law-breaking.
There are scenes of moderate peril, including a tense sequence where a character is suspended from a high-rise building.
Brief references to the difficult backgrounds of the kids (foster care, homelessness) are handled with care but are present.
Conversation Starters
"Sara hacked a system to expose a crime—when is it okay to break a rule to do something right?"
"If Mother recruited you for the team, what would your 'specialty' be and why?"
"Which of the five kids' backgrounds or skills did you relate to the most?"
"How does the team handle it when they don't agree on a plan?"