Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Check, Please! is basically the 'Ted Lasso' of graphic novels. It’s incredibly charming, focuses on healthy masculinity, and treats its characters with a level of kindness you don't always see in YA fiction.
It started as a webcomic and you can tell—the pacing is snappy and the humor feels very 'current.' While there’s some swearing and college-style partying, it’s far from gritty. It’s a top-tier recommendation for any kid looking for a story about finding your place and your people, especially if they're tired of high-stakes drama and just want something that feels like a warm hug (and a slice of pie).
Age Fit
Best for 13 or 14 and up. It’s set in a college environment, so the language and social scenes reflect that, but it's a very safe 'up-read' for mature middle schoolers.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
It models incredibly healthy friendships and a supportive team environment. While it deals with college-aged pressures, the tone remains optimistic and focuses on kindness, baking, and emotional growth.
Imaginative
78
The 'hockey player who is also a champion baker and vlogger' hook is fresh and breaks typical YA tropes. The art style is expressive and adds a lot of personality to the storytelling.
Safe
82
It's a book, so no digital 'traps.' Content-wise, it contains college-level swearing, social drinking, and references to romance/sex, but nothing gratuitous or 'unsafe' for its target teen audience.
Enriching
92
Excellent representation of LGBTQ+ identity and a masterclass in depicting healthy masculinity in a sports setting. It encourages empathy and staying true to yourself.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Subverts 'jock' stereotypes with a protagonist who loves baking and vlogging
Positive, low-stress LGBTQ+ representation that focuses on joy rather than just trauma
The 'found family' vibe of the hockey team is genuinely heartwarming
Fast-paced graphic novel format makes it a great 'gateway drug' for reluctant readers
⚠
What to Watch For
Casual college-level swearing (f-bombs included)
Depictions of college parties and social drinking
Off-page or implied sexual content consistent with a YA romance
Conversation Starters
"Bitty is terrified of being 'checked'—how do you handle it when you're scared of a specific part of something you otherwise love?"
"Why do you think the team was so supportive of Bitty? How does that compare to how sports teams are usually shown in movies?"
"If you had to make a 'mood pie' for how you're feeling today, what flavor would it be?"