Do I need to see the original Charmed to understand this one?

Not at all. This is a complete reboot with a new family, new town, and new lore. It occasionally nods to the original, but it's a standalone story.

How 'scary' is the show for a 10-year-old?

It's on the edge. There are demons, jump scares, and some creepy makeup effects. If your kid is sensitive to horror, they might find it intense, but for most it’s 'spooky-lite.'

Is there a lot of romance or sexual content?

It’s a CW show, so there is plenty of pining, kissing, and characters waking up in bed together (usually under the covers). It stays within TV-14 boundaries, so no explicit nudity.

Why are the online reviews so negative?

Most of the hate comes from fans of the original show who felt the reboot didn't respect the source material. If you go in without those expectations, it's just a standard, middle-of-the-road fantasy drama.

Charmed – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Charmed

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show2018

54%

WISE Score

4.8

IMDb

A modern update where the Vera sisters juggle college life, activist politics, and the sudden realization that their mother’s death was more than an accident.

4.8/10

48%

→

Charmed

show

TV-14, 2018

54%

WISE Score

4.8

IMDb

A modern update where the Vera sisters juggle college life, activist politics, and the sudden realization that their mother’s death was more than an accident.

4.8

Jump to

Also rated on

4.8/10

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

This 2018 reboot of Charmed is a bit of a slog. While it tries to do something new by setting the action in a college town and focusing on a more diverse cast, it lacks the chemistry and 'fun' factor that made the original 90s series a cult classic.

If your teen is obsessed with witchy vibes and has already burned through Sabrina or Wednesday, this might fill a gap, but don't expect a masterpiece. The low audience scores are a fair warning: it’s mediocre TV that often feels like it’s trying too hard to be relevant without nailing the storytelling basics first.

Age Fit

Best for 12 or 13 and up. It’s essentially a supernatural soap opera. If they’re old enough for Riverdale or The Vampire Diaries, they’re the target audience here.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The core of the show is about three sisters supporting each other through grief and power, which is a solid foundation. However, the CW-style relationship drama and occasional mean-girl tropes keep it from being truly wholesome.

Imaginative

It builds on existing lore while adding modern magical elements and diverse cultural mythologies, though it often sticks to very standard 'monster of the week' television structures.

Safe

Standard TV-14 fare. You'll see magical violence, some creature-feature scares, and plenty of romantic tension, but it rarely crosses into truly graphic or disturbing territory.

Enriching

It attempts to tackle social issues and identity politics, which can spark conversation, but the execution is often surface-level and secondary to the supernatural plotlines.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Modernized sisterhood that focuses on three women of color navigating a fictional college town together.
Diverse mythologies are brought into the mix, moving beyond the standard European-centric witchcraft tropes.
Approachable horror for teens who want a spooky vibe without the nightmare-inducing intensity of more mature series.

⚠

What to Watch For

The IMDb rating is a 4.8 for a reason; the writing can be clunky and the special effects often feel low-budget even for basic cable.
It leans heavily into political messaging that some find refreshing and others find heavy-handed or 'preachy' compared to the original series.
Magical violence is frequent, with demons being 'vanquished' in ways that might be a bit much for younger kids who aren't used to fantasy combat.

Conversation Starters

"How does the bond between Macy, Mel, and Maggie compare to how you and your siblings or friends handle stress?"
"If you suddenly discovered you had a 'destiny,' would you be excited or would you just want to go back to your normal life?"
"The show tries to talk about real-world problems through magic. Do you think that makes the message easier to understand or just more confusing?"

Deep Dive

The 'Power of Three' Gets an Update

When the Charmed reboot was announced, it faced an uphill battle. Fans of the Halliwell sisters were protective, and this new version—starring the Vera sisters in Hilltowne—didn't exactly win them over. The show swaps the San Francisco manor for a college campus, which changes the energy from 'family legacy' to 'young adult discovery.'

One of the biggest shifts is the tone. This version is much more overtly political. Mel is a graduate student and activist, and the show frequently uses magical metaphors to comment on real-world power dynamics. For some families, this is a great entry point for discussing social issues. For others, it can feel like the show is checking boxes rather than telling a compelling story.

Technical Hits and Misses

The special effects are... noticeable. In an era where streaming budgets have raised the bar for fantasy, Charmed often looks like a show from 2005. The demons and spell effects can be a bit 'plastic,' which actually might make it less scary for younger viewers, though it makes it harder for older ones to take the stakes seriously.

If you're looking for a show to watch with a middle-schooler who is just starting to get into fantasy, this is a safe enough bet. It covers themes of grief and responsibility, and the central mystery of their mother's death provides enough narrative hook to keep you clicking 'Next Episode' for a few nights. Just don't expect it to become your next family obsession.