Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Bravelands is a rock-solid choice for middle-grade readers who want to sink their teeth into a big series. It's the classic Erin Hunter formula—complex animal societies, a dash of mysticism, and a lot of high-stakes drama.
It isn't 'brain rot' by any stretch; it actually requires a fair amount of focus to track the different hierarchies and the overarching plot. Just know that it doesn't sugarcoat the savannah. Animals die, often at the paws of other animals. If your kid is the type to be devastated by the death of a fictional lion, maybe have some tissues ready or steer them toward something lighter.
Age Fit
Best for 9-to-12-year-olds who love animals and can handle some intensity. By 15, most kids will find the 'talking animal' tropes a bit too young.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72
The series centers on a 'Great Law' and the balance of nature, promoting a sense of community and order. However, it's built on a foundation of betrayal and survival-of-the-fittest drama that can feel a bit heavy.
Imaginative
88
Erin Hunter is the master of building complex non-human societies. The unique mythos for lions, baboons, and elephants—and how they intertwine—is top-tier world-building for this age group.
Safe
75
It's a book, so there are no digital safety traps. But 'safe' is relative here; the violence is frequent and sometimes graphic for an animal story. Main characters die, and 'Spirit-Eaters' implies some darker supernatural themes.
Enriching
78
It pushes kids to consider different perspectives and the ethics of leadership. It’s a great workout for empathy and understanding social structures beyond just 'good guys vs. bad guys.'
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Deep world-building that makes the African savannah feel like a living, breathing civilization.
Three distinct perspectives (lion, baboon, elephant) keep the narrative from getting stale.
It’s a massive 6-book arc that rewards kids who have the patience for long-form storytelling.
Perfect for the 'Warriors' fan who wants something slightly more exotic than neighborhood cats.
⚠
What to Watch For
The violence is 'nature red in tooth and claw'—don't be surprised by blood, bone, and favorite characters getting eaten.
Some of the spiritual themes, like the 'Spirit-Eaters,' can get a bit creepy for more sensitive readers.
It can be a bit slow-paced compared to modern action-heavy graphic novels.
Conversation Starters
"If you were a baboon, would you follow the 'Great Law' even if your leader was a total jerk?"
"Why do you think the different animals have such different rules for their tribes?"
"Is it ever okay to break the 'Code of Honor' to save a friend?"
"Which character's perspective did you like best: Fearless, Sky, or Thorn?"