Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is one of those rare picture books that doesn't sugarcoat the hard stuff. Cooper's spare text and bold illustrations create a story that's both achingly sad and quietly hopeful—big cat and little cat become friends, grow old together, and then the big cat dies. The little cat grieves, time passes, and eventually a new little cat arrives. It's the circle of life, but for house cats.

The Caldecott Honor is well-deserved. This isn't a book that lectures kids about feelings or wraps death in metaphor. It just shows it, simply and honestly, and trusts young readers to understand. The black-and-white art is gorgeous—kinetic, expressive, full of personality.

That said, this is not a book to pull out casually. If you're not ready to talk about death, or if your kid just lost a pet last week, maybe wait. But if you're looking for a tool to help process grief, or to introduce the concept of loss before it happens, this is as good as it gets. It'll make you cry, but in that good, necessary way.

Age Fit

Best for ages 4-8, especially when you're intentionally opening a conversation about loss, death, or saying goodbye to a pet. Older kids might appreciate it in the right context (after a family loss), but it skews younger in design.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

92

Unsentimental but deeply tender portrayal of companionship, aging, and loss. Models quiet care between the cats without being saccharine. The measured text and bold illustrations create an emotionally honest space that respects children's capacity to process grief. Described as 'quietly reassuring' by multiple reviewers.

Imaginative

78

Cooper's thick black lines create kinetic, personality-filled figures that invite close observation. The sparse text leaves room for children to fill in emotional beats and imagine the cats' inner lives. The visual storytelling—showing the passage of time through seasons and routines—encourages careful looking and interpretation. Not wildly fantastical, but thoughtfully designed to spark reflection.

Safe

75

The older cat dies and doesn't come back—this is the central emotional event. It's handled gently and without graphic detail, but it's still pet death, which can hit hard. Parents need to know this is coming. For families ready to discuss loss, it's age-appropriate and tender. For families not expecting it or with a child who recently lost a pet, it could be rough. The book itself is designed to be a grief companion, so the 'surprise' factor is the only safety concern.

Enriching

88

A 2018 Caldecott Honor book that tackles one of childhood's hardest lessons—how to keep going after loss. The cyclical structure (big cat becomes little cat, little cat becomes big cat) offers a concrete framework for understanding continuity and change. Builds emotional literacy and empathy. The 4.9 Amazon rating suggests it resonates deeply with families. This is a book with lasting impact, not just a one-time read.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Handles pet death with rare honesty and gentleness—no platitudes, just the quiet truth of companionship and moving forward
Bold black-and-white illustrations are stunning and kinetic; Cooper's thick lines give the cats real personality
The cyclical structure (lonely cat finds kitten, kitten grows up, cycle begins again) offers kids a concrete framework for understanding grief and continuity
Caldecott Honor recognition means this is picture-book craft at its finest
4.9 stars on Amazon—families find this genuinely helpful for processing loss

⚠

What to Watch For

The older cat dies. That's the story. Don't pick this up expecting a light read—it's beautiful but it will make you feel things
Best as an intentional choice when you're ready to talk about death, not a random library grab
If your family just lost a pet, this could be either exactly what you need or way too soon—trust your gut

Conversation Starters

"How do you think the big cat felt when the little cat first arrived? How did that change over time?"
"The book shows the cats doing the same things together—eating, playing, sleeping. What are some things you like to do with people (or pets) you love?"
"When the big cat doesn't come back, the little cat is alone again. But then what happens? What does that tell us?"
"Have you ever had to say goodbye to someone or something you loved? What helped you feel better?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Big Cat, Little Cat Elisha Cooper? Put this WISE score on your site