Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the real deal—serious literary fiction that doesn't pull punches. Celeste Ng has curated twenty stories that will make you uncomfortable, make you think, and occasionally make you gasp. Not everything here is pleasant, but it's all purposeful.
For parents of bookish older teens, this anthology can be gold. It's the kind of collection that sparks genuine discussion about values, empathy, and the human condition. But you need to preview it first—stories about obsession, mental illness, and other mature themes require emotional readiness.
The 4.2 Amazon rating suggests readers appreciate the quality even if some stories don't land for everyone. That's the nature of anthologies. If your teen is ready for adult literary fiction and you're willing to discuss challenging themes together, this is enriching stuff. If they're still in the Percy Jackson phase, save this for later.
Age Fit
Best for mature teens (15+) and adults who appreciate literary fiction. The thematic complexity and occasionally graphic content make this inappropriate for middle-grade readers. For families that value literary enrichment, this can be a powerful shared reading experience with older teens.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
62
Guest-edited by Celeste Ng, this anthology tackles grief, obsession, mental-health crises, and sexuality with literary nuance. Stories include 'a bereaved medical actress obsessed with a student' and 'a lethal running mania'—mature themes handled thoughtfully but not appropriate for younger readers. The emotional depth is age-appropriate for older teens and adults who can process complex moral questions, but the intensity and occasionally graphic situations mean it's not universally wholesome.
Imaginative
88
The Best American series showcases contemporary literary fiction at its finest—twenty diverse voices exploring everything from wild-animal estates to celebrity-look-alike mothers-for-hire. The publisher describes them as 'little tuning forks' that test readers' values, which captures the imaginative range. These aren't formulaic stories; they're boundary-pushing, thought-provoking narratives that invite readers to see the world through radically different lenses. Strong originality and creative storytelling.
Safe
55
For its intended adult/mature-teen audience, this is perfectly safe—no surprise content for someone picking up a literary anthology. However, the material routinely explores obsession, mental-health crises, and 'sometimes graphic or unsettling situations.' A younger reader stumbling into this would encounter themes well beyond their developmental readiness. The anthology doesn't come with content warnings, so parents need to preview stories before sharing with teens. Most appropriate for 15+.
Enriching
91
This is literary enrichment at its core. The anthology offers a snapshot of current American short fiction, featuring acclaimed contemporary voices and award-winning storytelling. For older teens and adults, it's a masterclass in empathy, ethics, and the role of fiction in reflecting society. The stories invite deep discussion about values, human nature, and moral complexity. High cognitive and ethical growth potential, plus genuine entertainment value for readers who appreciate literary craft.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Showcases diverse contemporary voices and award-winning storytelling from the year's best literary magazines
Stories function as 'little tuning forks' testing values—perfect for sparking deep discussions about empathy, ethics, and what it means to be human
Guest-edited by bestselling novelist Celeste Ng, ensuring high-quality curation and thematic coherence
Offers a snapshot of current literary trends and craft techniques for aspiring writers or serious readers
Available in multiple formats (hardcover, paperback, audio) at accessible price point
⚠
What to Watch For
Mature themes throughout—grief, obsession, mental-health crises, sexuality—that require emotional maturity to process
Some stories include graphic or unsettling situations (bereaved actress obsessed with student, lethal running mania)
No content warnings provided, so parents should preview before sharing with teens under 16
This is literary fiction, not beach reading—requires focus and willingness to sit with ambiguity and discomfort
Conversation Starters
"Which story made you most uncomfortable, and why do you think the author wanted you to feel that way?"
"The publisher calls these 'tuning forks' that test your values. Which story challenged your beliefs the most?"
"How do these contemporary stories reflect what's happening in society right now?"
"If you could have a conversation with one character from any story, who would it be and what would you ask?"
"Which story would you recommend to a friend, and which would you warn them about?"
